Married couples tax break reveals Conservatives are out of touch
A couple of weeks ago, on the long drive back to University, I found myself shouting loudly at the radio that my family had on in the car. As a sane individual who is not normally the radio-shouting type, this was rather worrying for those who know me.
The cause of this outburst of talkshow-related fury was a discussion of the policy the Conservatives unveiled going into their party conference: a tax break for married couples of 1000 pounds a year. This policy has been overshadowed a little by the later proposal of reduction of benefits to under-25s, but it seems to me that this policy is just as revealing about the attitudes of the Conservatives today. It is simple political pandering and is harmful, especially in the 21st century, in some of the assumptions it promotes.
What bothers me incredibly is the emphasis specifically on “married couples”. Don’t get me wrong, as someone who has been lucky enough to have two parents in a committed, stable marriage throughout my formative years, I understand the value of a nurturing family environment. Yes, relationships and households based on love and trust are essential to well-adjusted, happy individuals and societies.
But what planet are the Tories living on when they suggest that today – in the 21st century, after all the progress we’ve made to a more accepting, tolerant society – a loving, nurturing environment comes in one traditional, institutionalised size? All credit to them for proposing to include civil partnerships in the scheme. But still, by emphasising that one family structure is the ‘right’ way of going about things, they automatically devalue and discredit all of the other myriad ways that human beings love and relate to each other nowadays.
To suggest that widows and widowers should be ignored purely because of their misfortune in losing their spouses; that two people who have grown to hate one another should stick it out for the kids, poisoning their home environment by arguments and potentially abuse; that two people who haven’t gone to the trouble of getting a piece of paper from the registrar’s office can’t love one another and their children as much. All of this is hurting people who arguably need government economic and moral support more, and is pure pandering to the Daily Mail crowd and their so-called ‘traditional values.’
Furthermore, the tax break is only applicable when the couple’s earnings are unequal: one spouse must earn less than their personal non-taxable allowance (a little over £10,000). Surely to goodness there is a better way of providing an economic advantage to stable relationships than something that all but requires people not to be equal financial partners, and will probably end up becoming a dead letter in low income families where both partners need to work equally as hard just to make ends meet.
Now, I realise that the tax break’s actual impact will be minimal. An allowance of £1,000 per year is not going to radically restructure society, making everyone into brainwashed traditionalist drones of the government upholding marriage no matter what. It’s more a symbolic gesture on the part of the government. But then, what is really the point? When it comes down to it, implying that people will get married for the price of a portion of fish and chips a week is not only a deeply offensive slap in the face for non-traditional families, but insulting to the married couples themselves.
Photograph by UCL Occupation (Oscar Webb)

