Manet: Portraying Life
Walking around the Royal Academy’s ‘Manet: Portraying Life’ exhibition is a polarising experience of highs and lows. The genius of the artist being displayed cannot be denied as one is presented with portraits that brim with life, as the sitters are at once completely raw and believable while their preoccupations are also somehow lifted to a higher plain of nobility. This can be seen in Manet’s painting ‘The Railway’ in which the model stares out at the viewer with a book in her hand with an air of pensiveness, while progress in the form of the smoke of a train glides past the subject and across the canvas.
However, although there are certain works within the exhibit that illustrate Manet’s skill and creativity, there are also many paintings that do not. The showcasing of abandoned and unfinished works of art, although surely interesting for a passionate Manet enthusiast are, for a general visitor, just bad paintings – there was clearly a reason that the painter did not wish to continue these works and their place in such a mainstream exhibition seems strange.
Furthermore the whole concept of the exhibition seemed vaguely redundant. The organisers wished us to look at Manet with a fresh eye with the aim of examining the artist’s skill at portraiture, yet this idea was hardly groundbreaking as all of Manet’s work are in effect examples of portraiture (with the exception of a few nature studies). Even his paintings which are filled with people have a clear focus on each individual subject as they are painted with attention and detail. The entire concept of the exhibit seems as if it has been done before.
Now as a fan of the Royal Academy, I don’t wish to be completely scathing with my review. What I did find interesting was the artist’s painting of his friends who we can also recognise as popular figures (these included Monet, Baudelaire and Zola.) One of these works happened to be my favourite painting within the collection; ‘The Monet Family in Their Garden at Argenteuil’ exuded charm and was a magnetic depiction of a family at rest within a fertile landscape.
However, this star-spotting eventually only served to increase my feeling of disappointment. I felt that I should not have been at what was described as a “landmark” exhibition of this excellent painter solely to look out for famous figures in an almost Where’s Wally form of entertainment.
To conclude, the Royal Academy’s exhibition felt as if it was severely lacking. With only 54 works of art and an entire room dedicated to a map of Paris and some art books, perhaps the organisers found it difficult to gather all the paintings that they wanted to.
Although this is an understandable difficulty when working with a painter who is so in demand, what was most embarrassing was that the painting which was set out as the star piece and had a room to itself was the beautiful ‘Music in the Tuileries’ – a painting that can be seen for free at The National Gallery all year round.
Therefore although I did enjoy aspects of the exhibition, what stuck with me most was that it seemed rather insipid. I’d therefore have to agree with Adrian Searle’s comment for The Guardian that, “so much is missing, and quite a bit is missable, too.”
Photograph: Edouard Manet’s ‘The Monet Family in Their Garden at Argenteuil’ (1874) exuded charm as a magnetic depiction of a family at rest. Photograph: FlickrID ehtysrofnahtanoj

