Manchester United: a stuttering start to the season
By James Smith
As we enter the international break, Manchester United sit at seventh in the Premier League table, with four wins from twelve Premier League matches, having only kept two league clean sheets, and most importantly languishing nine points behind the Champions League places.
It will come as little surprise to hear that this has been Manchester United’s worse start to a top division campaign for some thirty years.
The Premier League season began for United with a flattering 4-0 victory at home over Chelsea on the 11th August – a result which on paper at least was encouraging for those around Old Trafford.
United’s season since then has stuttered.
It will come as little surprise to hear that this has been Manchester United’s worse start to a top division campaign for some thirty years
Much of the Red Devil’s season has been marred by lacklustre and uninspiring performances against lower, to mid-table teams in the division, as well as poor displays against average Europa League sides.
The statistics for United’s season thus far do not make for pretty reading. In eighteen games in all competitions this season they have scored only twenty-four goals, conceding fourteen in the process.
To put this into context, only Sheffield United and Bournemouth have scored fewer goals than Manchester United of the other top-ten sides.
So what is behind such a poor start to the season?
Their inconsistent run of form extends to the end of the 2018/19 campaign, where they won only three of their last ten league games, conceding 18 and scoring just 10 in that period.
Further, all of those wins came at Old Trafford, much like this season where United have not looked convincing on the road (aside from their Carabao Cup performance at Stamford Bridge).
A clear lack of firepower and creativity going forward has seemingly hampered their chances of convincingly beating opposing teams.
This seems to stem from the midfield of the team.
We have seen so far this campaign a lethargy to United’s build up play. When the ball has been won in transition they have been slow to feed their attacking players, making them mostly easy to defend against. Similarly, their build-up play has been increasingly sideward, as if the players in the middle of the park do not have the confidence to take risks moving the ball forward at pace.
This is perhaps unsurprising given that Juan Mata is the most experienced player in their midfield, and at thirty-one not the player that a long-lasting team can be built around.
When we consider the United attack in comparison with the attractive and clinical offensive powers of City, Liverpool, and Chelsea it isn’t hard to see how the Red Devil’s front line is greatly lacking the conviction it needs to consistently challenge for the top four.
This was a criticism levelled at them in the days of Mourinho, and sadly seems to have perpetuated under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer.
It must be noted however, that Paul Pogba has been missing for a lot of the 2019/20 campaign and despite what criticisms have been thrown his way during his second spell at the club, it is undeniable that the player has fantastic ability and quality on the ball which is missed when he is out of the side.
A lack of leadership on the pitch is met with a lack of quality
The problems in the midfield however, have not been shown consistently all season. In the game against Liverpool and the two against Chelsea, Manchester United moved the ball from front to back with great pace, exploiting their opposition when they committed men forward.
This was the same in their last fixture against Brighton, where the Red Devils looked imperious on the attack, and were decisive in cutting through (an admittedly naïve) Brighton defensive line.
Further, in the game against Liverpool, we saw an energised United team that were prepared to work off the ball, and to take risks. This clearly paid dividends in the first half as the Liverpool full backs were effectively forced deeper – preventing them causing damage to the United back line.
Not only was this an impressive tactical display, it also showed that at times United can cause their opposition problems – however as the game continued it seemed inevitable that Liverpool would score, as they did.
The question that follows, therefore, is why have United not been able to replicate these performances against lesser opposition? The most obvious, and perhaps accurate, explanation is a lack of desire and leadership across the board, and in some places a lack of quality.
The work effort displayed in the aforementioned games against top sides showed fantastic levels of desire, however when we compare this to their performances away at West Ham, at Newcastle, and Bournemouth it is as if they were a completely different team.
True, these three games (none of which United won) were away, and therefore supposedly harder – for a team of Manchester United’s pedigree this really shouldn’t be any excuse. But when we look at those performances, at how the Red Devil’s players seemingly wilted under the pressure of being behind away from home is surely worrying for their fans.

United entered the game against Bournemouth in high spirits, having won three on the bounce in all competitions; they started the game positively and created chances. Yet when Bournemouth were able to score through Josh King on forty-five minutes, the away side were suddenly stuck for answers and nobody in the team was willing to lead by example and pull his teammates back into the game.
They bounced back, as mentioned, at Old Trafford to win 3-1 against Brighton. They cannot however, rely on their home form all season, and in reality they need either to bring in some experience to their first team, or their younger players need to step up and prove that they are worthy to play for such a historic club.
This lack of leadership on the pitch is met with a lack of quality at times. Whilst Rashford and Martial have proved themselves as perfectly decent Premiership strikers it seems that neither are yet at the stages of their career where they are going to be netting twenty league goals each. This must be a real concern for Solskjaer as there are few other players in his dressing room who he can really rely upon to score consistently.
Rashford’s creativity has been shown in glimpses this season – especially in the last match against Brighton – but as the main striker at such a big club, he cannot afford to be at his best for only a handful of matches a season.
This is similarly matched by the creative limitations of the midfield players discussed earlier, so even if a top-level striker was to arrive at Old Trafford, there is no guarantee that they would receive the sort of service that they need.
However, it is certainly not all doom and gloom for the red half of Manchester. Whilst Rashford and Martial are not yet top-level strikers, they are both blessed with the benefit of time to improve – Rashford especially.
Further, for the first time in years seemingly, United invested well in the summer, bringing in Maguire, Wan-Bissaka, and James who all look likely to develop into much better players.
However, at this time it looks as if United’s transfer policy from the seasons before has not benefited the current manager as he currently has a squad that must improve and be bolstered before it can realistically challenge for the top four.
So where do United go from here? Most importantly both the fans and the board need to back the manager and commit to a long-term strategy rather than reverting to splashing cash on ‘big’ players for a quick fix.
United’s transfer policy from the seasons before has not benefited the current manager
This is possibly a problem that is rooted deeply in Ed Woodward’s presence at the club. Certainly opinion is not in the man’s favour, as his directorship of the club has seen the same recruitment mistakes being made time and time again.
Further, the constant rumours that sporting decisions are made by non-footballing people at the club are doing nothing to ease the manager’s relationship with the board, nor keeping moral up in the changing room.
The question of Paul Pogba also needs to be answered. Following a summer where rumours about his desire to leave continued, and criticism of his quality and his desire were commonplace, the manger and the board need to make a decision about whether they ‘force’ him to stay and see out his contract, or whether they cash in and hope to recover as much of the millions they splashed on him. What is clear though, is that whilst his future is in doubt it is not helping their on-field pursuits.
The question of Paul Pogba also needs to be answered
Manchester United currently possess a squad that has the potential to develop if given the chance, and if they are boosted by a couple of signings in the middle of the park and some support for Rashford going forward.
Most importantly though, they have a manger who, although he may not be the greatest tactician in the world, certainly has the desire and passion for Manchester United that is in fact invaluable at a club at such a crossroads.
What is clear though is that he needs time to sort out what are some very major issues both on and off the pitch. Whether he or his successor will receive this remains to be seen.
Image by Mula Miszczu via Pixabay
