Man up close: the male mental health stigma

By Lily Boulter

When you want to create an awkward atmosphere, bring up suicide. The taboo surrounding mental health is argued to be especially true amongst men and specifically young men. This extends to university students. Professor Green’s recent documentary Suicide and Me has called to light the serious problem of mental health stigma among young men. Suicide is the biggest killer of men under 45 in the UK. In 2013, 78% of suicides in the UK were male while a higher percentage of women were diagnosed with depression. The documentary highlighted the role stigma plays in men not seeking help. In a university environment, it can be argued that ‘lad culture’ perpetuates this problem. Emotional expression opposes the stereotypical masculine image; as a result phrases such as “man up” and “grow a pair” are bandied around rather than “tell me how you feel”. Why are men’s mental health issues going so underreported? Does the idea of being a ‘lad’ play a role? Is language a contributing factor?

Men who are less likely to seek help have been found to endorse traditional masculine ideology and find it harder to express emotions according to a study published by the British Journal of Health Psychology in January of this year. The idea of showing vulnerability by crying or seeking help is shunned in a society that promotes the ‘macho’ stereotype. The word ‘macho’ in fact comes from the Spanish ‘male animal’ and harps back to the old-fashioned idea that men must be viewed as the strong character and the unnatural emotional side must be suppressed – “man up”. The question needs to be asked: is enforcing this stereotype worth it? If every time you say “man up” or “grow a pair”, you are preventing someone from sharing their emotions, adding to the build up of stress or anger or self-hatred, would you think twice about saying it? It does not even have to be this extreme; language subconsciously feeds our minds as does our behaviour. The idea that crying makes you seem weak needs to be inverted. A sharing of emotions should be promoted; as Professor Green asks, if someone can see you laugh, why can they not see you cry?

Another question needing answering is this: why young people? The statistics show young people dominating a shocking proportion of mental illness cases. One important factor is that young men do not talk about mental health. Even more shocking is that evidence from men at our university supports this. According to the County Durham Public Mental Health Strategy 2013-2017, “men have measurably lower access to the social support of friends, relatives and community and are less likely than women to seek help for emotional health”. In contrast to this, one member of our men’s rugby team argued team sports offer a support network in themselves. However, the same individual went on to say that whilst mental health should not be stigmatised, it still is. A common ground for the men we asked about why this exists was a lack of understanding. This knowledge gap, as one person suggested, excludes those with mental health issues as “different” and “strange”, being isolated by another’s unawareness. Instead of asking questions, people are more likely to retreat or exclude; however unintentional the outcome is, people’s reactions stem from ignorance rather than intolerance. How to tackle this can be problematic in itself. Being of the generation that missed these lessons in school, university students now have to combat this. Could we enforce these PSHE-style classes at university? Could this be an opportunity for social media to play a positive role, informing people about the what, why, how and what to do about it? Interestingly, one of the people interviewed drew the parallel between high profile sportsmen coming out as gay and the need for high profile individuals to speak out more, as Professor Green has done. It could be argued that the information is there; people can understand if they choose but they are not actively seeking to. Involving high profile people, using more visible social media campaigns and enforcing university-level education will get people talking and will help to reduce the stigma. Schemes are in place and campaigns are running but evidently more is needed.

Lastly, just because this article focuses on mental health issues amongst men does not deter, detract or belittle all mental health issues. It is making the case for mental health awareness. Every year one in four people experience mental ill-health. People need help to recognise this and seek help. A crucial part of that help is talking and feeling comfortable to do so. The scary thing when addressing men’s mental illness is that underreporting may mean levels of mental health problems are higher than the already-too-high statistics. We need to man up and talk about mental health.

Photograph: id-iom via Flickr