Male mental illness in film: Is it enough?

By Anton Blaubach

With an abundance of readily available streaming services that allow our ever-shorter attention spans to be entertained, cinema acts as a heavy influence on our perceptions and opinions. A frequent complaint towards Hollywood has been lack of positive representations of male characters coping with mental illness. In return, this perpetuates feelings of forlornness in the relevant demographic. The question stands: is enough being done to erase the stigma around mental illness in men?

Having watched Beautiful Boy, I think it is a great example of a film that takes drug addiction and mental trauma head on. No one is ever blamed for the addiction in the course of the film and with no signs of mental or physical trauma during Nic’s childhood, his adult state comes as a shock. Nic Sheff himself said that one of the things he hopes people will take from this film is that ‘addiction is a disease not a choice’. In a study headed by Dr. Stacy L. Smith in May 2019, from a sample of nearly 5,000, only 1.7% of characters portrayed in popular films were shown with a mental health condition. Meanwhile, the television statistic stood at 7% – this is still far below the roughly 25% of Britons who experience a mental health problem every year.

Nonetheless, if we have targeted films (like Beautiful Boy) that directly address mental health, then perhaps these are more important than having a representative portion of mentally ill characters across all film and television. The criticism about representation on screen is a difficult one to make because it depends on one’s view of the purpose of cinema – do filmmakers have a responsibility for the influence they might have on viewers? If we see cinema as shapers of society and of our culture, then maybe being representative should be of utmost import to filmmakers.

Being representative should be of utmost import

Joker, the highest grossing R-rated movie of all time, has become a highly contentious piece of cinema since its release. After protagonist Arthur Fleck is no longer able to receive his medication due to cuts to social welfare funding, his transformation into the Joker begins. The film makes it ambiguous whether the lack of medication plays any role in bringing about his violent craze. Although this is an extreme case of mental illness, it shows the emotional state that one can be left in if a victim of mental sickness is left alone and untreated. On the other hand, some have accused the film’s hackneyed link between violence and mental disorder as continuing stigma. Perhaps then, just because a character in film is depicted with a mental illness, the way in which it is conveyed can actually adversely affect our understanding of it and of coping mechanisms.

These films are enabling conversations about mental health

Whatever your opinion of the aforementioned films and whether they give an accurate representation of men’s mental illness, the silver lining is that people are having these conversations. As a global audience, we are constantly engaging with our art and observing our relationship with it, and ultimately, this does hold some influence on the art made for our entertainment. It may be long before the film industry satisfactorily addresses these issues. However, the most important thing is that these films are enabling conversations about mental health.

Image via Peakpx