Making sense of common sense
By William Webb and Nicholas Goedeking
Bank bashing, the practice of blaming investment banks for society’s woes, has been increasingly scrutinized in recent months, with more moderate voices taking over the now less emotional debate about the power financial institutions yield in the economy. In Durham, however, ‘bank bashing’ appears to have never really been an issue at all.
When confronted, students often either adopt a very balanced view saying things like “you cannot really say that the crisis was solely the banks’ fault,” or they start a neoclassical rant about how the Walrusian equilibrium will always prevails. Ideological debates aside, we believe there are four points to be made, and all students, especially those aspiring to work in the financial industry, should be made aware of them.
First, banks are not the most important aspect of an economy. It is shocking how reluctantly this point is often accepted (if at all). Many don’t even seem to be conscientious of it, which probably has to do with the role financial institutions play in the UK’s economy.
But anyone who ever took a basic undergraduate economics course should know this. Banks do not generate any wealth per se. In a crude sense, all they are providing is a service within the monetary cycle to convert savings into investments. It is this investment into labour, capital, R&D, infrastructure, technology, etc. which then generates growth (different models will emphasize different factors). Banks aren’t unimportant, but they are by no means the economy’s vanguard.
Second, realizing that financial institutions only play one part within the economy, it may strike some as odd how much influence these institutions and particularly financial markets yield within the real economy. Creating public ownership in form of stocks was undoubtedly an ingenious invention, linking financial with real markets. But this does not justify why, speaking in a broader economic context, maximising share-holder value held against quarterly benchmarks has come to dominate corporate objectives instead of sustainable long term growth; that many large US corporations are reporting record breaking profit margins despite the US economy’s turmoil is indicative of this, as is, on a larger scale, our severe continuing reliance on ecological exploitation.
Third, on a more theoretical level, one does not have to be an expert on an issue to legitimately criticize that issue. We may be generalizing here, but economics students, when confronted with a debate about the financial crisis, tend to say things like “It’s more complicated than that. You wouldn’t understand”. But this line of argument is flawed: I am perfectly entitled to criticize ends, even if I do not understand the means.
When Goldman Sachs sets aside $15.38 billion in 2010 and $12.22 billion in 2011 to pay compensation and benefits to its employees, while the US unemployment rate is somewhere around 9-10% for that same period (up from around 3-4% before the crisis), I do not have to understand why these bankers get so much money in order to criticize that decision. Regardless of the reasoning behind the procedure (which is often a slippery-slope argument of the “It’s complicated.” kind), if the results are unfair, they are unfair. Put in a slightly more drastic and polemic way: I don’t need a Ph.D. in nuclear physics to be legitimized to condone the downsides of a nuclear holocaust.
Fourth, assuming (a) something is going wrong in the financial sector and (b) that I have a legitimate criticism of what I believe is fundamentally going wrong in the financial sector, the question becomes, how should I express my criticism? The adequate ‘tone of voice’ will depend on what is at stake and how much attention I get. If, for sake of argument, the world economy is at stake and nobody is really paying any attention to a fundamental problem – that private vices may not yield public benefits after all, for example – the logical consequence is to be loud; in fact, very loud.
The following analogy may help. Imagine a group of unsupervised children playing with fire in a back yard. Imagine furthermore that you are justified to believe the situation could get out of control. Do you go up to the group of children and say “Excuse me, I couldn’t help but notice you are possibly allowing something bad to happen. Could you please do me a favour and stop playing with the fire? Please.” or will you say in plain English “Stop playing with the fire!”? We believe the latter is simply commonsensical.

