Making a splash
This newspaper has in the past been the subject of satire for being a little too keen to mention those former editors who have done well for themselves in the media.
Perhaps the Durham alumnus with the most interesting journalism career, however, never worked for this newspaper: Sylvester Bolam graduated from Armstrong College in Newcastle with an economics degree. He died young, but has entered into the colourful history of Fleet Street as an important cautionary tale about the tightrope relationship between press freedom and the law.
As editor of The Daily Mirror (at the time when it was the most popular daily paper in the country), Bolam became associated with a style known as ‘sensationalism’, which he vigorously defended: “The Mirror’s a sensational paper, but sensationalism doesn’t mean the distortion of the truth. It means the vivid and dramatic presentation of events so as to give them a forceful impact on the mind of the reader.”
This approach to news, however, landed him in Brixton prison for three months, following his paper’s florid reporting of the 1949 arrest of John Haig, ‘the acid bath murderer’ – which was deemed to have influenced the trial.
Not long after his release, at the age of 47, he died. The legacy of the style he defended – the vivid and dramatic presentation of events – is the quite extraordinary and often disturbing behaviour of the British tabloids. But it is probably wise to read this monstrous press activity as a reaction to the central difficulty with newspapers: they are not a very good way of making money.
The industry as a whole is constantly scrimping and saving, meaning it is less able to afford costly investigative journalism and more fear of expensive confrontations with the notorious British libel laws. Not to mention greater dependency on the goodwill of advertisers, a heavier emphasis on cheap journalism like opinion articles, and of course a desperation to get people to pick up the damn thing – sensationalism.
It’s not until you’ve tried out a bit of news-gathering and reportage yourself, though, that you understand the temptation to make a splash. This week Palatinate received an email tip-off about an alleged spew of University buildings which have achieved the lowest possible rating – G – for energy efficiency. Some of these buildings are quite recently constructed, including the Calman Learning Centre (CLC) and the Ogden Centre. Our first thought was – ‘excellent, a story’.
On further investigation, however, what looks like a scandal is really nothing of the sort. The Display Energy Certificates, DECs, which provide this numerical and graded rating for all public buildings, are generated by a computer program that feeds in limited data.
Reading through the accompanying advisory reports, it is easy to see how generic they are. Moreover, some of these G ratings are attributed automatically in the absence of sufficient data. The CLC, for example, falls into this category. After speaking to the people responsible for engineering specific energy efficiency solutions for University buildings, you realise how easily a bit of shoddy reportage could anger the experts.
So we have resisted the desire to make a fuss over nothing, and we will endeavour to do so in the future, lest we end up editing The Sun.
