Love Island: the cost of entertainment value
By Chloe Hares
For eight weeks of summer, millions of us were tuning in nightly for an hour’s fix of this year’s Love Island – the game of love or money in which the contestants’ lives are never the same post-villa. These singles go from an isolated Big Brother style villa in which they look for a romantic connection, to being thrown back into the real world in which they are targeted by tabloids and scouted by brands on social media. While many slam the contestants as shallow airheads, they face a number of struggles as a contestant which brings us to the question: how far can we allow reality shows for entertainment when it is costing people their mental health?
Firstly, there is the struggle with adjusting to villa life, and manipulation by producers. This year, contestant Liam Llewellyn made the decision to leave the villa after just three days, stating that he ‘hadn’t been himself’, leading many to suspect this was down to the unnatural interference of producers in how the islanders go about their time during the day. Previous islanders such as Amy Hart have shared that while on the show no one has any concept of time as there are no clocks anywhere. Shaughna Phillips also admitted that producers had suggested lines they wanted to catch on camera from her while conversing with her co-stars. It is likely factors like this may have contributed to Liam’s departure, realising that his mental health may suffer if he were to continue in this environment.
ITV2 seem completely okay with treating contestants like puppets, with little consideration for their feelings
Though the show appears very natural, and some may be inclined to believe my points to be a stretch, Season Four contestant Niall Aslam actually entered a stress-induced psychotic episode due to this villa style of life, which he was far more hypersensitive to due to his autism – which he disclosed with ITV2 before appearing on the show. However, it seems issues that matter the producers fail to acknowledge – such as the thousands of Ofcom complaints this year about Luca Bish’s bullying of Tasha Ghori, or Woman Aid’s statement about the manipulative nature of Adam Collard in Season Four. With all this considered, it does cross one’s mind to what extent Love Island qualifies as a ‘reality’ show, especially looking at its success rate of couples staying together.
There is a preconception among the general public of Islanders, and a stereotype that they must be shallow airheads to enter a competition like Love Island. This can be damaging because those who choose to be on the show have no power over how the public perceive them. Again, producers choose what we see and don’t see – many islanders have come out on podcasts about many things which have happened in the day which never made the cut into an hour’s episode for that day. The public constantly compare new islanders to those from previous series, criticising their judgement and sometimes even mocking their appearance. This year, on the show’s weekly spin off ‘Aftersun’, Laura Whitmore even encouraged viewers to keep tweeting the lookalikes of the islanders, with no regard for how islanders may later feel upon seeing these. Regardless of how distant we are from these people; it is still classified bullying of which there is no need for – this is another way that mental health is shattered by the show. ITV2 seem completely okay with treating contestants like puppets, with little consideration for their feelings.
We live in an inherently prying society, and we are all so quick to happily share our opinions on multiple public platforms
Life beyond the villa has also proven damaging for Islanders, some not able to escape their previous mistakes made on the show, or who have fallen into a celebrity lifestyle which has gotten them into trouble. Previous contestants Sophie Gradon and Mike Thalassitis both took their own lives sometime after appearing on the show. It is believed both had turned to using cocaine and suffered majorly with their mental health, feeling they had no better options in life. They were both subject to much media attention in their last years, so we must question whether this would have been their fate had they not participated in Love Island.
Alas, we live in an inherently prying society, and we are all so quick to happily share our opinions on multiple public platforms. Love Island will continue to be recommissioned for years to come, because regardless of what any of us have to say about it, we continue to tune in so that we can form these opinions. It appears to be something of a circus, contestants in the ring doing what they have to do, while we sit back as an audience and watch.
Image Credit: Pexels

