Love Island: a pseudo platform for love and inclusivity

By Samya Amir

Love Island is a dating reality show that emerged in the United Kingdom in 2005. The British reality TV show has been the subject of various controversies, some of which revolve around borderline misogynistic behaviour and bullying. On 19th July 2022, the show attracted over 1,500 complaints to media regulator Ofcom over alleged misogynistic behaviour by male contestants. This is regarding the ‘Snog, Marry, Pie’ challenge, where contestants exposed who they would kiss, marry, or hit in the face with a cream pie. Two contestants, Luca Bish and Dami Hope, were accused of bullying one of the contestants, Tasha Ghouri. Although the men apologised, they received severe backlash, which caused Bish’s sister to post on Instagram in an attempt to clear her brother’s name.

This year, 23-year-old model and dancer, Tasha Ghouri from Thirsk, North Yorkshire entered the villa. Ghouri is the first deaf contestant to have been brought to the show and was keen to educate the islanders and viewers on her “superpower” — her cochlear implant. However, whilst this is a step towards diversity, the show seems to be contradictory to their inclusivity propaganda when the producers only entertain and promote the perfectly chiseled male contestants, who display a fixation with a type that is overwhelmingly ‘blonde and blue-eyed women’.

There is something deeply problematic about a show wherein female success is often predicated on validation from white men

A different problem arises altogether when darker-skinned Asian women are left out of the equation completely, as producers continue to cast from the ‘palatable’ end of South Asian beauty. Although it may be argued that Love Island is the wrong show to look at to seek representation, it must be highlighted that the target audience for this show is mainly women belonging to the age group of 16-34. If these women don’t see adequate representation on media, it can leave them feeling unwanted and undesirable. This argument does not only run in terms of the colourist attitude followed on the show, but also the lack of body diversity. With only two to four Asian representations in the previous seasons, practically only one plus-size contestant and now one disabled contestant, it may be argued that the inclusivity and diversity proposed in the show is only on a surface level and remains questionable. Having a very small number of contestants from unconventional backgrounds in a course of eight seasons is reflective of the tokenistic ‘inclusive’ nature of the show.

Unfortunately, this lack of body diversity in the show is likely to severely negatively impact ITV2’s target audience. There is something deeply problematic about a show wherein female success is often predicated on validation from white men. Additionally, the female representation in the show also remains problematic. Younger women are naively given the idea that they will only be appreciated and loved if they look a certain way. This may result in the younger generations adopting unhealthy lifestyles to look more objectively pleasing to society. It is important to take note that between 1.25 to 3.4 million people in the UK are affected by eating disorders. Around 25% of those affected are males.

On top of all this, the show seems to be unable to draw a line between love and lust, remaining rather satirical for it be titled ‘Love’ Island

On top of all this, the show seems to be unable to draw a line between love and lust, remaining rather satirical for it be titled ‘Love’ Island. The show also continues to restrict itself to cisgender, straight contestants. While one can see that it might be complicated to change that, it all adds up to a show that’s out of step with where we’re at in 2022.

From the economic aspect of it, the show manages to get over three million views, thereby giving the contestants various earning opportunities once they leave the villa. So, what are the effects of the extra series being added in 2023? We have two stakeholders for the case at hand. One being the actual contestants who gain money, fame and, if lucky enough, maybe love; and the other gaining party remains the Government, which makes money indirectly through personal tax due to the increased earning capacities of the contestants. On the other side of the spectrum, we also have the public — the viewers who have been seeing the same bodies, almost the same colour of people and the same plot being followed over the years. This lack of relatability in terms of representation can be taxing for underrepresented communities.

Moreover, the tokenistic representation on the show could be doing more harm than good. Ultimately, when we weigh the two sides, it is undeniable that the series contributes economically but is that acceptable at the cost of creating severe body image issues among the public? Maybe not but, seeing that the show will have extra series next year, the only thing we can hope for is a little justice to the public by encouraging more representation in the show in terms of colour, body and sexuality.

Illustration: Lollie Sillitoe