Louis Theroux triumphs in the West Bank

by Adam Seddon

Louis Theroux has had quite a journey as a TV personality. His first high-profile work was his Weird Weekends series, featuring bizarre sub-cultures. Now he is beginning to develop a reputation for higher-brow gonzo journalism – essentially the practice of covering stories from his own perspective and through personal experiences. In Ultra Zionists Theroux turns his attentions to Israel, and the people whose lives are bound up in one of the most politically controversial disputes of the modern age.

Theroux spends most of this documentary in the company of Daniel, who represents the interests of an Israeli group which buys up property in Palestinian neighbourhoods and installs Jewish tenants. The practice is illegal, and condemned even by the US – Israel’s most indulgent ally.

Daniel offers two explanations. The first is capitalistic: if the Palestinians wish to sell, and the Jews wish to buy, why should they be obstructed? But the properties are clearly bought for several times their value and given to Israelis at knock down prices, which is why the Palestinians are willing to sell (despite the threat of being ostracised by their communities) and why the Jews are willing to live in a violently hostile neighbourhood. That is a perversion of capitalism. The second is a more convincing explanation: Daniel believes all Israel, including the Palestinian territories, is divinely bequeathed to him and his fellow Jews. When Theroux asks if Daniel feels responsible for exacerbating the mutual aggression in the region, Daniel elevates the discussion: “Smell that. You can feel King David. He’s here.”

Louis speaks to other people. At one point Daniel’s armoured car is stoned by a child. In the face of Daniel’s indignation, a Palestinian onlooker remarks: “It’s nothing. You drop five-ton bombs on kids”. Another Palestinian youth demonstrates the long-term prospects of insurgent violence. He asks Louis: if Israelis killed your people, wouldn’t you want to kill them too? No doubt many Israelis could pose the same question about Palestinians. The sense of injustice on the ground is mutual and intense. But Daniel is of most interest because he is representative of the mechanism by which the conflict continues. Israeli expansion into Palestinian territory is facilitated by affluent Jews, at the pay of wealthier ones, on the basis of ideology. They are assisted by foreigners who have no conception of the political situation but have read the Old Testament and concluded the Jews are the chosen race. They also rely on the Israeli army to protect their minority presence, leaving Palestinians to watch as Daniel busily repopulates their communities under the permanent threat of armed response to any perceived resistance.

By trying to understand Daniel’s motivations, Theroux opens up the reasoning that drives those whose behaviour ensures the perpetual escalation of unrest and ethnic tension in Israel. He never exhibits strong feelings, even in the face of appalling comments, but that is his strength as a journalist.

His curious sangfroid creates a kind of placid bubble around him, even in chaotic situations. When he invites somebody inside, they seem to disarm immediately, and project at least understanding – if not sympathy – onto the blankness of his face. He coaxes people into revealing why they really do what they do, and in a situation like Israel, that is fascinating.