Lord Pannick KC “If I only defended people I liked, I would be unemployed.”

By Krishan Sharma

“If I only defended people I liked, I would be unemployed.” Lord Pannick KC delivers this remark during our interview for the Bar and Mooting Society. It is a striking statement, one that encapsulates the ethical dilemmas inherent in a barrister’s role and one that he will spend the rest of the interview justifying. Having spent decades navigating the complexities of advocacy at the highest levels, Lord Pannick has faced public scrutiny for the clients he represents. Yet, in our discussion, he is unwavering in his justification: a barrister’s duty is to represent their client to the best of their ability, regardless of personal views or public opinion.

“You wouldn’t expect a surgeon to refuse to operate on a patient because they dislike them,” he explains. “The same applies to barristers.”

It is a principle he returns to repeatedly throughout our conversation. In a legal system built on the right to representation, barristers must act as advocates, not arbiters of morality. Their role is not to pass judgment but to ensure that the legal process functions as it should.

Lord Pannick is no stranger to controversy. Over a career spanning more than four decades, from junior counsel to taking silk, and now as a sitting member of the House of Lords, he has been at the forefront of some of the most high-profile legal battles in the UK. His clientele has ranged from prime ministers to global institutions, appearing before the Supreme Court and in the back chambers of parliamentary committees. His work has helped shape constitutional law through landmark cases, cementing his reputation as one of the country’s foremost legal minds.

You wouldn’t expect a surgeon to refuse to operate on a patient because they dislike then. The same applies to barristers

Having represented figures such as Boris Johnson, Gina Miller, and Manchester City FC, he has often found himself the target of public criticism. When he defended Boris Johnson before the House of Commons Privileges Committee over allegations of misleading Parliament, he told me that his inbox was inundated with messages questioning his integrity. “Curious how you sleep at night,” read one email. Another simply called him a “sad, sad man.”

Yet, he remains unfazed. He acknowledges that people often conflate law with politics and misunderstand the barrister’s role. “My job is to argue the case, not to express my personal opinions,” he says firmly. He notes that his position in the House of Lords allows him to voice his views on legal and constitutional matters, but in the courtroom, his role is distinct. Advocacy is about process, not personal belief.

When I asked whether he has ever refused a case on grounds of controversy, he shook his head. “That would go against the very nature of what we do,” he explains. If barristers started picking and choosing cases based on public opinion, it would undermine the entire foundation of the justice system. In fact, he argues, to turn down a case is itself a political act. “Once you start choosing who to represent, you are, in effect, choosing a side.” It is this principle that forms the bedrock of his justification for representing contentious clients.

Public perception of advocacy, he acknowledges, has become increasingly hostile. “I was condemned for representing Gina Miller,” he recalls. “Some thought I was interfering in politics. Others criticised my involvement in the Shamima Begum case. But these reactions are nothing new.”

He points to historical examples to illustrate his point. “Quintilian accused advocates of ‘snatching criminals from punishment.’ John Stuart Mill claimed that ‘putting on a wig and gown’ exempted a man from truth and justice. The suspicion towards lawyers has always existed.”

But, he argues, advocacy is fundamental to a fair legal system. “It is the judge and jury who decide guilt or innocence, not the barrister. Our job is to ensure that every argument is put forward properly.” He references the fictional barrister Rumpole of the Bailey, who, when criticised for defending a murderer, retorted: “I defend murderers; that does not mean I defend murder.” The distinction, Lord Pannick insists, is crucial.

It is the judge or jury that decide guilt or innocence, no the barrister. Our job is to ensure that every argument is put forward properly

However, he concedes that this principle depends on the integrity of the legal system itself. “In regimes like Nazi Germany or apartheid South Africa, the courts were tools of oppression. In such cases, the ethics of representation are fundamentally different.” A just legal system, he stresses, must be built on impartiality and fairness.

A central pillar of the barrister’s role is the ‘cab rank rule.’ This professional obligation requires barristers to take on cases on a first-come, first-served basis, regardless of personal opinion.

If we say that some people do not deserve representation, where do we draw the line? It’s a dangerous precedent

“Michael Leavery once put it best,” Lord Pannick recalls. “When asked why he was arguing a case that contradicted his stance from the previous day, he replied: ‘My Lord, I am simply a taxi for hire.’ That captures it perfectly.”

Yet, he acknowledges that this principle is not always understood by the wider public. The increasing scrutiny of lawyers, particularly those defending unpopular clients, has led to heated debates over the ethical responsibilities of barristers. “There is a real misunderstanding of what we do,” he says. “We are not endorsing our clients. We are ensuring that justice is done.” This, he argues, is a message that needs to be shared more widely to dispel misconceptions about the profession.

Lord Pannick is keen to emphasise that without legal representation, the justice system would collapse. “If we say that some people do not deserve representation, where do we draw the line?” he asks. “It’s a dangerous precedent.”

As the conversation shifts to the qualities of an effective advocate, he is unequivocal: “Preparation is everything.” He explains that a barrister must know the case better than anyone else in the room. “A barrister who is unprepared is a barrister who will lose.”

Beyond preparation, he highlights the importance of persuasion and composure. “A courtroom is a place of high tension. The ability to remain calm under pressure is essential. You are being watched—by the judge, by the jury, by your opponent. Every word matters.”

Reflecting on his own career, he acknowledges the role that both hard work and opportunity have played. “Luck is always a factor,” he admits. “But luck only helps those who put themselves in the right position to take advantage of it.”

Advocacy is not about agreeing with your client; it is about ensuring that their voice is heard and their case is given the due process it deserves

For aspiring barristers, he offers a final piece of advice. “Make yourself visible”. He advises future barristers to take every opportunity to develop their skills, and remember that the most important quality in an advocate is resilience. You will face setbacks, criticism, and difficult cases. But if you are committed to the principles of justice, you will find the work incredibly rewarding.

As the interview draws to a close, he reiterates a point he has made throughout: “Advocacy is not about agreeing with your client; it is about ensuring that their voice is heard and their case is given the due process it deserves.”

In an era where public opinion often blurs the line between advocate and client, Lord Pannick’s steadfast commitment to the principles of justice serves as a powerful reminder of the role barristers play in upholding the rule of law. His words stand as both a defence of the profession and a call to those who seek to understand it: justice must be available to all, no matter how unpopular the case.

Image: Lord Pannick