Lizards or leaders: what does the future of the World Economic Forum look like?
By Hope Stoney
The mood was bleak as global leaders met in Davos in the Swiss Alps for the annual World Economic Forum (WEF) meeting last month. In his address, UN Secretary-General António Guterres warned “Let’s be clear…we are in the worst situation I remember in my lifetime”. With the concurrent crises of Covid-19, climate change, economic slowdown, and the biggest war in Europe since 1945, global cooperation has scarcely been so vital. But, as the dust settles after the event, many have questioned the WEF’s usefulness in the face of these colossal challenges.
The WEF was set up in 1971 by young businessman and academic, Klaus Schwab, as a project to foster public-private sector cooperation. The aim is to bring together CEOs, heads of state, and leaders in civil society to improve the state of the world. Schwab founded The Forum on the theory of stakeholder capitalism which suggests that companies should be accountable to all parts of society.
Since its founding, much of history has been played out on the Davos stage. In 1986, Greek and Turkish Prime Ministers met for the first time and started the process of normalizing relations, closely avoiding war. In 1992, Nelson Mandela shook hands with President F. W. de Klerk; an image that marked the end of apartheid in South Africa. In 1998, the G20 was born at Davos. In 2007, WEF warned of too much risk in the financial system and spent the following years in crisis management mode.
A large part of this success is owed to the fact that top shots love to rub shoulders with similarly powerful people. But this year, while 52 leaders did attend, key players were missing. Joe Biden, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin were all absent. In fact, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz was the only G7 head of state that made the meeting. While it is rash to suggest this marks the beginning of the end for globalisation as some are suggesting, it is a mistake for these leaders to skip the summit given there has not been a more pressing need for global leadership.
It is a mistake for these leaders to skip the summit given there has not been a more pressing need for global leadership
Davos has long been criticised for the irony of asking the jet-setting global elite to solve the issues of poverty and global heating. Many argue we should not be expecting the people responsible for much of global injustice to solve the very problems they create. This criticism tends to fall under what political scientist Samuel Huntington coined the ‘Davos Man’: a transnational elitist who aims to come across as a benign benefactor but just spouts empty talk. On the opening day of the summit, Oxfam released inequality statistics that show the top one percent captured nearly two-thirds of all new wealth created in the last two years, whilst global poverty has increased for the first time in 25 years. Anti-Davos protestors, who predictably come every year in their droves, pointed to the juxtaposition of over 100 billionaires attending panels on how to tackle global hunger and the cost-of-living crisis.
A related criticism is that those most responsible for the looming climate disaster are the very people attending the meeting so, despite climate change being high on the agenda, little progress is likely to be made. In 2020, Greta Thunberg memorably told the meeting “Our house is on fire” and blamed attendees for fuelling the flames. This year, UN Secretary-General António Guterres accused attendees of peddling ‘the big lie’; it has recently been discovered that ExxonMobil accurately predicted and modelled climate change in the 1970s but has since spent the last decades trying to cast doubt over that very climate science. Greta Thunberg argues that we should be listening to people on the frontline of the climate crisis rather than those most responsible for emissions.
The WEF has certainly set itself a tough challenge
The WEF has certainly set itself a tough challenge to fix the most serious problems whilst maintaining the capitalist status quo. Those that defend the current system would likely say that capitalism has lifted innumerable people from poverty, has starkly improved living standards, and continues to drive innovation and opportunity. If you accept that business has a role to play, and that progress comes through scrutiny and cooperation, Davos still has an important place in the world. While much of what goes on in Davos is for corporate interest (including the parties!), it is also one of the only times in the year when business leaders are challenged on their social and environmental targets. WEF Membership for a company can cost anywhere between $125,000 to $500,000 depending on the size of the organisation and the number of delegates being sent. Meanwhile, journalists, NGOs, activists, and social entrepreneurs get hugely subsidised or free entry. This means that the most powerful CEOs and senior officials are easily accessible for rigorous and public questioning without backup from aides and advisors.
The WEF is also self-conscious about criticism of the ‘Davos Man’ and over the past couple of years has increasingly shifted its focus to creating a more inclusive and sustainable global economy. Research by LSE found that since 2014 mentions of ‘growth’ in WEF press releases halved while words related to environmentalism increased more than threefold. Meanwhile, reporting has increasingly covered tangible impact rather than flimsy discourse. The WEF is not going to suggest overthrowing the current system, but it does push companies toward a fairer, more responsible capitalism. Progress may be frustratingly slow, but given the WEF is encouraging courageous leadership to create a fairer system, many argue it should stay. Perhaps instead of criticising the conference itself, we should turn our attention to the politicians who do not turn up, and the business leaders who do not listen to what they have to say.
Image: World Economic Forum via Wikimedia Commons

