Living on campus: the role of the campus novel
By Connie Castle
Having recently read a review of one of the most popular novels of 2019, Sally Rooney’s Normal People, I was particularly struck by the reviewer scathingly asking ‘do we really need more novels about university students in love?’.
However, Rooney’s Normal People, and David Nicholls’ One Day are anything but simplistic fairy-tales about doomed soulmates or soppy teenagers. Both authors use the unique intimacy and intensity of modern university romances in order to explore the more complex nature of relationships, and ultimately their significant effect on the individual. For them, university is a backdrop that works as a time of change and personal growth, and acts as a springboard from which characters can be introduced and their lives mapped, demonstrating the ways a relationship can influence the people we become.
Do we really need more novels about university students in love?
Perhaps significantly, neither novel begins with fresher’s week. In fact, One Day finds Emma and Dexter the night after their graduation, on their final day at Edinburgh University. The novel continues following their lives, but only on this day, the 15th July, each year. In this way, the novel doesn’t focus on university life, but the contrast between our expectations of life after university, and the reality.
In contrast, Normal People begins during Marianne and Connell’s final year of school and demonstrates the way rigid social hierarchies are completely reversed outside of this insular environment. In both novels, university facilitates a relationship between the characters, suggesting that this period of freedom in the life of a young adult enables romances that would be unimaginable at home. Emma believes the arrogant and self-assured Dexter is out of her league, and Connell sees Marianne’s wealth as a reason their relationship could never truly work. University creates a bubble where two young people can live independent from their pasts and their families, a place in which the fantasy of these relationships can become a reality.
Just because these novels concern young people living through tangled romantic relationships does not mean they are without value
Having not read One Day for a few years, I initially thought I preferred Rooney’s novel. I found the immediacy of her present tense narrative and the intensity and perceptiveness with which she narrates the inner lives of her characters both striking and original. However, going back to One Day has reminded me of its light-hearted humour. Emma and Dexter, unlike Rooney’s protagonists, are extremely likeable characters. The novel’s incredibly poignant final chapter confirms that it by no means pales in comparison to Rooney’s so called ‘modern classic’.
Both these novels are so interesting to read, particularly as a university student, because they feel relatable. They capture both the hesitation and exhilaration of a young person facing a completely uncertain future. Similarly, while excruciating to read, all the mistakes, timidity and misjudgements of the protagonists are realistic, and make us wonder whether someone we almost rejected or didn’t meet, living down the corridor or sitting behind us in lectures might actually be someone unmissable. Just because these novels concern young people living through tangled romantic relationships does not mean they are without value.
While most would agree that it is unrealistic for incoming freshers to begin university expecting to meet a soulmate that will alter the course of their life, this will undoubtedly be a time where you will form incredibly important relationships (romantic or otherwise). Like the long-forgotten photo of Emma and Dexter’s graduation found in the novel’s final scenes, the bond of this lasting love, the same ‘goodness, like a gift’ that Connell gives to Marianne in Normal People, outlasts and transcends the confines of a traditional friendship. In these novels, we are reminded of how much joy our relationships can give us; and ultimately the way those around us shape our lives.
Photo by Vasily Koloda via Unsplash
