Lines blurred over censorship during Freshers’ Week
Controversy over Robin Thicke’s ‘Blurred Lines’ grew earlier this month, as debates emerged about whether it should be played during Freshers’ Week events.
Following in Edinburgh University’s footsteps, some Durham Colleges decided to boycott the song across the week due to its “degrading” content, leaving other colleges the subject of criticism.
St. John’s, St. Mary’s and St. Chad’s Colleges as well as St. Cuthbert’s Society banded together with several Student Union officers at JCR Presidents’ Committee (PresComm), a fortnightly meeting of all College JCR Presidents, to promote the idea of banning the song in Durham.
Josephine Butler College held a vote involving over sixty members of the college in order to decide whether the song should be stricken from their Freshers’ Week playlist.
Will Kendall, Josephine Butler College’s JCR President, remarked: “It was a unanimous decision that it should not be included in our in-house playlist and it had no disruption on what was an excellent Freshers’ Week.”
Hatfield College, however, decided not to ban the song, which currently ranks No. 9 on Spotify and No. 32 on the UK chart after its release in March.
One Hatfield Fresher was in support of their decision, arguing: “I don’t believe that they should be banning any forms of art. It’s morally questionable, even if the subject matter is controversial.”
On a nationwide level, the National Union of Students (NUS) sucessfully placed pressure on SUBtv, a music channel which holds the contract for many student union buildings (including Dunelm House) to remove the song from all of its playlists.
Therefore, ‘Blurred Lines’ will not be played anywhere in the Union building.
Studio is currently the only one of Durham’s clubs to have openly instructed its DJs not to play the song following a campaign led by St. Chad’s College Senior Woman, Chloe Williamson.
Williamson commented: “If this song being banned in several establishments makes artists think twice about including degrading lyrics in their songs then that can only be a good thing.
“I think that it’s fair to say that this song not being played will not upset many people, but this song being played has the potential to upset a minority of people in a major way.”
This movement has also been adopted by the University of Derby, Leeds University, Kingston University, and the University of West Scotland.
Some students, however, have questioned the targeting of this particular song.
A second year from St Mary’s College said: “I don’t know why people have such an issue with it. It’s no different from other sexual imagery in most pop songs.”
Durham University Feminist Society’s Publicity Officer, Florence Perry, commented on this criticism, noting: “Obviously, we are aware that this is not an isolated incident, but it has become somewhat of a poster boy, which means it would have the biggest impact.”
She continued: “It is lines like ‘good girl’ and ‘the way you grab me’ that encourage the idea that all girls naturally want to be dominated and normalises victim naming. There should be nothing that a girl can say other than the obvious that means I want to have sex.
“Wouldn’t it be nice if rape victims didn’t have to listen to such lines, which are often used by rapists, every time they go to Klute?”
The song also made a significant appearance in Durham University Feminism Society’s publicity campaign, where members of the public were asked to write the reason why they need feminism on a whiteboard.
Comments such as, “No, Robin Thicke, I don’t want it,” featured prominently in the responses.
The topic has been widely debated in the national press, with Thicke claiming that the song and its video were meant to create a point about the industry’s attitude towards the portrayal of women.
He argues: “We tried to do everything that was taboo: Bestiality, drug injections, and everything that is completely derogatory towards women. Because all three of us are happily married with children, we were like, ‘We’re the perfect guys to make fun of this.’”
Emily Ratajkowski, one of the models who starred in the controversial video has said of her role in the video: “It’s something very important for young women today to have that confidence. [The video] is actually celebrating women and their bodies.”
Photograph: Flickr Images

