Licence in Literature: 1920 to 2020
By Natasha Ketel
The year 1920 was trapped in the thick of literary modernism: a period when novels were treated as impenetrable puzzles and writers aimed to “make it new”. At the time when T.S. Eliot, Virginia Woolf and James Joyce were publishing work, there was an undeniable narcissistic fascination with the workings of language and the uncertain limitations of literary form.
a period when novels were treated as impenetrable puzzles
This unrestrained desperation to experiment, and the writers’ obsession with human interiority led to the popularity of the stream-of-consciousness form, still evident in the work of some authors today. For example, the lullaby-like, tantalising prose that marks out Max Porter as one of our most astonishing contemporary writers is heavily reminiscent of Woolf’s experimentation with multiple voices, pushing the boundaries of the written word.
Yet it has been acknowledged that novelists today may borrow aspects of modernist techniques, but imbue them with a contemporary edge, usually creating work with greater realism. Even though the extent to which the form and style of the novel has altered in the past 100 years can be debated, it is clear-cut that the content and themes, have become far more diverse and accessible.
During the year 1920 itself, D.H. Lawrence published his infamous novel Women in Love, earning him his reputation as one of the greatest breakers of taboos. The story follows the Brangwen sisters, Gudrun and Ursula, and focuses on their romantic relationships, careers and domestic lives. The polarisation of gender and repression of homosexuality in the novel are pivotal in displaying how far literature has progressed in terms of what is deemed acceptable by the reader. Lawrence’s women are educated, professional, political, strong and often violent examples of the ‘New Woman’, a feminist ideal that emerged in the 19th century, due to their sexual independence and ambitious work ethic. Yet they are still restricted by patriarchal oppression, reflecting the attitudes of the times.
These traditional attitudes towards gender, often seen in works of modernism, are further exposed through Lawrence’s inability to explicitly display homosexuality in Women in Love. The subtle inclusion of sexual tension between two men, is most evident in the eroticised wrestling scene, when Lawrence focuses on the ideas of flesh and penetration: ‘So the two men entwined and wrestled with each other, working nearer and nearer […] he seemed to penetrate into Gerald’s more solid, more diffuse bulk, to interfuse his body through the body of the other. It was as if Birkin’s whole physical intelligence interpenetrated into Gerald’s body as if his fine sublimated energy entered into the flesh of the fuller man’.
the LGBTQ+ community is finally being acknowledged, respected and celebrated in literature
Turn to 100 years later and Ocean Vuong’s authentic depiction of male intimacy in On Earth We’re Briefly Gorgeous, a coming-of-age novel dubbed by TIME magazine as a ‘daring tale of queer love and pain’, reveals how the LGBTQ+ community is finally being acknowledged, respected and celebrated in literature. There is a monumental honesty underlying the sexual attraction between Little Dog, the Vietnamese-American narrator, and Trevor, the man he meets whilst working during the summer. Little Dog’s sexual experience, heavily inspired by the diaries of the American artist and AIDS activist David Wojnarowic, allows him to appreciate the beauty of his body for the first time. This acknowledgement that he is worthy of the deep affection that he most genuinely desires would never have been permitted in Lawrence’s work, underlining the profundity of such progress.
Even though both Women in Love and On Earth We’re Briefly Gorgeous have similar aims to navigate honest human emotions and transgress boundaries in their exploration of sexuality, their differences exemplify how literature has become so much more tolerant and permissive in the last 100 years, as we would hope and expect.
Image: Joao Tzanno on Unsplash
