Library fines total £167,979 for 2009/10

by Mei Leng Yew

The total income generated from library fines by the University was £167, 979 in the academic year 2009/2010. This sum was collected from students and staff who returned borrowed resources after their due date, or who reported them lost or stolen.

The amount raised is significant as it is almost twice the sum raised by Newcastle University’s libraries. At £89,053, Newcastle’s potential income is restricted by the £10 maximum that students can be charged for overdue books. No such limit is in place in Durham.

However, the University insists that the current system of fines is fair and necessary to the continued running of the library. University Librarian Jon Purcell said, “Fines are used, in part, to buy replacement copies of lost or stolen books and for the provision of library services, such as 24-7 staff cover during exam revision periods, for example.”

However, the fact remains that this sum is largely raised by charges levied upon students who already pay a large sum to the University for access to the library resources in the first place. The rates are also regarded by many students to be unreasonably steep, as the total fine levied can accumulate rapidly.

A book from the Short Loan Collection which may be borrowed for up to four hours  will cost £1 for every hour if overdue, while those on a Three Day Loan are charged at £1 per day. Resources borrowed for a Standard Loan Period however, will only incur fines of 20p per day overdue. On the other hand, once a book is recalled by another student, the charge increases to £1 per day if the book is not returned by the new due date. If it is a Standard Loan, the new due date will be seven days later, or fourteen days later if during the summer vacation. If it is a Three Day Loan, the book must be returned immediately. Damaged books also incur hefty charges which some students have complained seem disproportionate to the cost of replacing the books.

Purcell defended the fines: “Library late fees are not in place to generate revenue, but instead are an incentive to return resources on-time so they can be re-circulated for other borrowers.”

In practice, this system has caused problems for students who have borrowed library books over the holiday period but who have had a loan recalled. With Royal Mail charging £4.41 to send a standard parcel weighing up to 2kg and taking at least three working days to arrive, it can be cheaper for students to hold on to their overdue loan until they return to the University and can deliver the book in person.

Whether you choose to return your recalled loan by post or to hold on to it, you may still incur additional charges. As the Easter vacation period is almost five weeks long, students who take books home for the holidays will plan to renew their loans at least once. However, if one book is recalled and the total fine reaches £5 or more, the student is unable to renew any of their other loans. This means that resources which have not been recalled and which might have been renewed up to ten times, will begin to incur charges once the due date passes.

Removing the right to renew unrecalled books seems an unreasonable punishment when a monetary charge has already been applied to the initial overdue loan. It also seems particularly unfair when this Easter, students have reported problems paying off their library fines online.

James Day, an English student at Grey, tried to pay a fine for overdue books but was unable to do so, “The system isn’t registering the fine when I try and pay for it. I now have over £5 of fines and can’t request any books myself. It’s a stupid system when you can request books over the holidays.”

The online renewal system was down for approximately three days over the Easter holidays, leading to fines being unfairly issued. However, students who have complained have had their fines made void or been reimbursed.

Nonetheless, for many, the current system is reasonable as demand for particular texts is always high in the run-up to the examination period. Additionally, all students are made aware that loan periods and charges do not change for the vacation period and there are many who accordingly opt to remain in Durham City over the term break in order to have access to the library’s resources.

The library has not increased fines since 2002.

£167, 979 would pay for

The tuition fees of 48 home students doing undergraduate degrees

3,359,580 black + white A4 photocopies

A standard loan book being overdue for 839, 895 days or over 2300 years.

******

The title of this article was previously “Library fines soar to £167, 979” and has now been edited to reflect the fact that this figure is in line with the total annual fines collected over previous academic years.

It was also incorrectly stated that Three Day Loans incur a charge of £1 an hour when overdue. In fact, the charge is £1 a day while overdue books from the Short Loan Collection would cost a student £1 per hour.

The library’s response to this article can be found here.