Letter to the Editor: our selection process for Editor-in-Chief must change

 

Disclaimer: the author of this piece recently ran for Editor-in-Chief and was not selected.

By Daniel Fox

Dear Editors-in-Chief,

This is not an attack on Palatinate. In my eyes, Palatinate remains the most important tool for Durham students to hold various bodies to account. However, I have serious concerns about the current process for selecting the Editor-in-Chief.

The process is currently as follows: the applicants complete a lengthy application form and are invited to hust in front of the 50-or-so members of the editorial board. The board then votes on who they would like to lead them. There is then an interview with the two sitting Editors-in-Chief and three members of the Students’ Union. The editors make the final decision.

For the last few rounds the person who the editorial board voted for has been selected.  No complaints here. However, last week the editorial board voted for a candidate (albeit by two votes) and a different candidate was selected by the current Editors-in-Chief.

Whatever you think about this process, it is incorrect to call it democratic. This piece is a plea to change it.

Very few organisations in the world allow the incumbent leader to appoint their successor. The Democratic People’s Republic of Korea is one. Palatinate is another.

Even in organisations which are not shining beacons of democracy, think FIFA, think the Catholic Church, the incumbent isn’t the ultimate arbiter of the decision to choose their successor.

There are fundamental reasons as to why a leader should not appoint their successor. Humans are humans. That leader is likely to prefer someone who has similar ideas to their own and is of a similar background to them. This means that the direction of the organisation will stay broadly constant through the successions and one particular group of people will come to dominate its leadership. This leads to stagnation and a stifling of ideas.

Take Palatinate as an example. In the hust in question, one candidate was somewhat critical of the direction in which Palatinate was being taken. They won the vote but were not chosen by the current Editors-in-Chief. Now, it is perfectly understandable that the editors might decide not to choose that person. They probably hold different views and so will view the ideas of the other candidate as preferable. However, this doesn’t make it right.

It is often not ‘bad’ people who cause sinister things to happen – but bad institutions and bad processes. This is a bad process. If the board voted for a candidate who was critical, then the board as a whole probably agreed with that candidate. However, as it stands the opinions of the 51 people on the editorial board are not taken into account.

This is dangerous.

Palatinate is supposed to represent the interests of all the students of Durham. If it cannot represent the interests of even its own editorial board, then it is a far cry from representing the interests of Durham students.

Palatinate is supposed to exist to hold other organisations to account. It will struggle to do this if its own editors cannot be held to account by the editorial board.

Palatinate prides itself on the independence of its editorial line. Allowing the current editors to handpick their successor limits the direction which this line can take. This is not independence.

I am aware of the counter argument: the current editors know most about how to run a paper and they can see the candidate throughout the whole application process. Thus they are best placed to make the decision… Simply put, this means that the current Editors-in-Chief should be able to overrule the rest of the editorial board.

I see flaws with this argument. It seems  pessimistic to presume that the editorial board will not vote for who will run the paper best. The members of this board put a lot of time and effort into Palatinate. They believe in the paper; that is why they work for it. They will vote accordingly. Therefore, it seems presumptuous – and even arrogant – to presume that the Editors-in-Chief will anoint more wisely than the rest of Palatinate.

I propose a change for going forward.

Distribute the application forms to the board before the vote. Invite the board to watch the interviews if they so wish. Have the decision entirely based on the vote of the editorial board. It is untrue to say that the board cannot make as informed a decision as the Editors-in-Chief.

Palatinate has been critical of Durham Union Society. It has pointed out the low voter turnout in Students’ Union elections. It has critiqued the University on its lack of a policy on sexual violence. This is all right. It is only fair that Palatinate’s own failings be exposed and corrected.

For an organisation which prides itself on promoting democracy, its leadership is dangerously undemocratic and unaccountable. This needs to change. My call is for the appointment of Editor-in-Chief to be entirely based on the vote of the editorial board.

 

Statement from the Editors:

Since Daniel raised these concerns we have agreed to review the process by which we select our Editor-in-Chief internally in an open discussion with the editorial board.

We defend the current process as voting is just one of four components, including interviews with members of the Students’ Union, that influences the final decision.