Lesbian Enigma: Society’s failure to understand lesbianism
By Magali O’Brien
A lesbian is a woman or nonbinary person exclusively attracted to people who aren’t men. Given that the white, cisgender, heterosexual man remains our societal blueprint even today, different corners of society can be reluctant to understand the lesbian identity as entirely divorced from men.
Lesbian Sexual Attraction and Men
Despite lesbian sexual attraction excluding men, most mainstream lesbian representation is made for male consumption. In mainstream porn, the dissonance between the identity represented onscreen and the intended audience is interesting to dissect. After all, straight porn is made for straight men and gay porn is made for gay men. But mainstream lesbian porn isn’t made for lesbians. In an interview with VICE, lesbians explained that the unrealistic aspects of lesbian porn made it a turn off for them. A common complaint was the lack of sensuality, the overuse of scissoring, and the common inclusion of men. Lesbian sexuality is modified for the male audience in the mainstream porn industry.
We see this trend in mainstream cinema’s portrayals of lesbians as well. Blue Is the Warmest Color, one of the most well-known lesbian movies, was directed by a man and includes a 7-minute long sex scene. Mainstream films choose to either avoid representing lesbian sex, since the reality is unappealing to a male audience, or to transform it into a performance for men, thus making it unappealing to lesbians.
The inclusion of men in lesbian sexual attraction is not restrained to media and the porn industry, however. It’s widespread in real life as well. A frequent response to lesbians coming out is an accusation of them hiding or misunderstanding their attraction to men. And an unfortunately common experience is men offering to help them unlock their secret attraction to them. The absurd reality is clear: there is a staunch refusal to see lesbians as wholly unattracted to men.
This expectation of male attraction ends up affecting lesbians. In lesbian culture, the term “comphet”—short for compulsive heterosexuality—explains phenomena of performative heterosexuality observed in many young lesbians. The tendency to become obsessed with unattainable men or force oneself into unfulfilling heterosexual relationships is a way many lesbians try to conform to the pressures of a society that demands male involvement in sexual attraction.
The “Himbo”
Lesbian culture itself is marked by attempts to reintegrate a culture centered around men. Appreciation for Harry Styles, Hozier, and Thor can be explained as lesbians admiring people who attract the genders they’re attracted to, but the pressure on lesbians to like men cannot be ignored when examining this phenomenon. While the lesbians who love Hozier are not necessarily lesbians suffering from comphet, they may be searching for another kind of male connection: a more platonic one.
It seems strange that lesbians continue to iconize the heterosexual male friend even when they have queer friends they can discuss crushes with. This phenomenon grows even more interesting once we consider the lesbian culture centered around the “himbo”. The “himbo” is a male figure approved by the general lesbian community and possessing these 3 characteristics: conventional attractiveness, simple-mindedness, and a non-threatening presence.
The difference between the imaginary lesbian created by the heterosexual man, a threesome fantasy, and the imaginary heterosexual man created by the lesbian, the harmless bestie, can explain the himbo’s characteristics. While the lesbian wants a male friend, the threat of being sexualized is terrifying, so the comforting ideal of a man who is simple-minded and non-threatening is born. Lesbian culture iconizes men who will befriend them without the possibility of sexualization: reintegration of patriarchal culture minus the exploitation.
At the end of the day, lesbians are not for men to enjoy nor are they misandrists
Lesbianism is the Practice
Even in progressive political spheres, lesbianism isn’t separated from men. In some feminist narratives, lesbianism no longer exists as an identity divorced from men, but rather as a political identity that opposes men. Second-wave feminism was famous for believing sexuality was a choice and, thus, lesbianism was a choice to stand against men.
The more recent TERF rhetoric operates in the same manner, though here it turns lesbians against imaginary “men”. These imagined biological males parade as women to infiltrate lesbian spaces. The lesbian becomes a political weapon as TERFs, like J. K. Rowling, claim transgender women are a threat to lesbians. This politicization not only, once more, frames lesbianism around men, but also causes harm to trans lesbians.
While the influence of men upon the lesbian identity can be benign (ex: the himbo), we must fight against more problematic interpretations of the lesbian identity. At the end of the day, lesbians are not for men to enjoy nor are they misandrists. They are simply a community devoid of people attracted to those who identify as men.
Image: Leonardo Rivello via Flickr
