Legitimacy, fairness, and government failure: 2021 A-Level fiasco
By James Dodsworth
Every aspect of life in the United Kingdom has been impacted by emergency restrictions and measures since the Covid-19 outbreak began here in March 2020. The schooling of the nation’s children is an area where restrictions have been felt profoundly. The idea of entire cohorts of sixth form students not sitting their A-Level exams would have seemed unimaginable when I was amongst the last cohort to sit them in 2019. However, this is the situation in which we now find ourselves as a country.
Whilst there was no perfect solution for awarding students the grades they worked for during their courses, there is a strong feeling that the Secretary of State for Education, the Rt. Hon. Gavin Williamson MP, has failed in his task of providing a fair system.
The much-derided algorithm that was initially used last year provided A-level results that were in line with previous years’ results. The previous performance of the school was an important factor in determining results. Whilst on the surface these results may have appeared fair and legitimate, they hugely disadvantaged students who excelled at under-performing schools, whilst grade inflation in many areas of the private sector became apparent. This led to widespread outrage across the country. A government U-turn resulted in the use of teacher predicted grades as result grades, leading to record high of results in 2020. Teacher predicted grades were again used in 2021, leading to results that were higher still than in 2020, on average.
The government has created a crisis in confidence for employers and universities alike
Despite the admirable intentions of reducing the importance of which schools students went to, and awarding grades that were supposedly fairer to the students receiving them, this system was a disaster. The 2021 A-Level results, and to a slightly lesser extent those received in 2020, are arguably borderline illegitimate. They are in no way comparable to the results received by the 2019 cohort, and those that preceded them, who were given the opportunity to take their exams. 2021 saw 44.3 percent of grades awarded be an A or above, in comparison to 2019 where that figure was 25.2 percent.
To suggest that those who would have taken their exams in 2021 were nearly twice as capable of getting top grades, compared to those that did so in 2019, is absurd. The government has created a crisis in confidence for employers and universities alike, with the return of widespread university entrance exams being a potential outcome.
Teachers should not be chastised for these results. Predictions for grades, even when based upon strictly assessed internal work, are likely to be higher than results obtained in the exam hall. You cannot expect teachers to be able to predict how students would hypothetically respond to the intensity of being externally examined. Every school has students that will underperform compared to expectations, and it is impossible for teachers to predict who will crumble under exam pressure. Based on all this, and in the interest of fairness, most would agree that exams should return next year, with a special focus on facilitating a full return to normal for A-Levels. It is the least students deserve.
Many would agree that Gavin Williamson has embarrassed the government with his performance in office
Many have said that Gavin Williamson must take responsibility for the plethora of very arguable failures he has overseen as Secretary of State for Education since the start of the pandemic. Some would go so far as to say that he has managed to unite the country around his incompetent handling of schools during the pandemic, with a ConservativeHome poll revealing a score of negative 44.1 for Mr. Williamson amongst Conservative Party members. For reference, Liz Truss tops the poll, with a positive score of 88.6, whilst Chancellor of the Exchequer Rishi Sunak scores plus 74.1.
Many on both the left and right would agree that Gavin Williamson has embarrassed the government with his performance in office. Some would say that Williamson has made it far harder for the Tory Party to portray itself as one of competence and stability; as the contrast to Labour, who the Tories have historically accused of being chaotic and unstable. For those of us who support the Tories, or even campaign on the doorstep for them, attempting to defend this fiasco is an unenviable task and one that most are not willing to do. Many would be glad of Williamson’s resignation or sacking.
Image: dcJohn via Flickr

