Legislation would force professionals to speak up
By Ellie de la Bedoyere
The ex-director of Public Prosecutions, Keir Starmer, has reopened the floodgates on opinion surrounding the way society deals – or, more importantly, fails to deal – with child abuse. In the BBC’s Panaroma programme, Mr. Starmer calls for mandatory reporting of child abuse, proposing that professionals working in close contact with children who do not report child abuse suspicions should face prosecution. The Department of Education, however, has rejected mandatory reporting, arguing it actually makes the child “less safe” (spokesperson for Department of Education, Telegraph) and that the professional guidelines already available are “crystal clear” and thus offer sufficient protection.
However, quite clearly they do not offer sufficient protection, and it is naive to assume otherwise. Take a look at a few of the famous cases recently reported – the victims (Baby P, Daniel Pelka and Keanu Williams) or the newest member on the predator list, Jimmy Savile – these are not just cases of horrific child abuse, but also cases of long-standing neglect at the hands of the professionals that surrounded each child. Liz Dux, of law firm Slater & Gordon, representing 60 of Savile’s victims, believes that mandatory reporting could have made Savile’s crimes known to the police as early as 1964, and that without changes to the law, “we risk another Savile case” (The Guardian). And, these are just the obvious cases of institutions failing children and by implication, allowing the continuation of their abuse; let’s not forget the countless cases that slip pass the public eye.

I am not someone who readily advocates anything that lies in the margins of a ‘Big Brother’ state – i.e. where a community transforms from ‘neighbourhood watch’ to a collection of ‘state spies’ – leaving people afraid to do or think anything. In the case of child abuse, what we want to avoid is a situation where suspicions are rashly reported, healthy families are torn apart and everyone tiptoes around each other nervously, fearing the punitive power of their neighbours. However, let’s not get ahead of ourselves: Keir Starmer is hardly proposing the renewal of Stalin’s totalitarian state. Instead, Mr. Starmer recommends that professionals – i.e. doctors, teachers, priests and social workers – who suspect child abuse and fail to report it, should be prosecuted.
This does not make reporting suspicions a legal obligation for all of society, which would greatly increase the likelihood of such false and destructive accusations against families through creating a fearful and suspicious mentality. Rather, Mr. Starmer’s proposals encourage those who have a professional relationship and work in close contact with a child to fulfil their responsibility to that child. Most importantly, what these proposals would do is create a front-line against child abuse.
If someone who works with a child in such a position of authority, purposefully or accidentally overlooks child abuse they should be legally reprimanded: to purposefully or to ignorantly ignore signs of abuse is a case of neglect. And, although such negligence may not be a criminal offence, it is certainly criminal.
If a parent or guardian is failing, then who else is looking out for that child other than a teacher, or a social worker, or a doctor? Who else is in close enough proximity to a child, and professionally trained to spot signs of abuse? Undeniably, there is already an unwritten social and moral responsibility that figures of authority have towards children in their care, so why not stretch it to a legal responsibility and establish this as the first, and most effective, barricade to sustained child abuse? Would we not merely be enshrining in legislation what should already happen?
This article does not intend to point a finger of blame at these professionals – that would be entirely unreasonable. Firstly, abuse is not always obvious. Secondly, it is unfair to blame someone for being hesitant about potentially destroying a family based on a niggling feeling or suspicion; indeed it is hard to take that mental leap from a suspicion to the unthinkable. Moreover it is particularly unfair to expect this when guidelines for what to do are unclear, tentative and not confirmed by a centralised law. While mandatory reporting is, of course, not the sole answer, it does remove that crucial hesitation by taking away the individual’s choice about reporting their suspicions and responsibility for that decision, as it would become a legal obligation.
Whatever your opinion about this proposed legislation, it is undeniable that in every one of these cases an adult in a professional capacity close to that child has failed. They have either failed to notice, or even worse, have failed to report what they have noticed.
There are certainly a number of factors within this, including an overstretched, underfunded state education system which means that teachers are unable to give children the individual attention they need, and the equally overstretched, underfunded, bureaucratic disaster that is Social Services. I do not suggest mandatory reporting is a solution, only a step in the right direction.
Those who may have previously hesitated to act on suspicions would be forced to. Those who might not have wholly engaged with their responsibility to notice child abuse will have to. And, if it is clarity that the Department of Education advocates, nothing makes something clearer than punitive legislation.
Photograph: Agriculture and Stock Department
