Lebanon in limbo: Paris in the Middle East

ramseynasser

By Harriet Tinker

The irony of the US Embassy in Beirut’s recent travel advice to “exercise extreme caution in western-style areas” and “pay close attention to personal security at locations where westerners generally are known to congregate” was not lost on the Lebanese.

Within hours, locals had begun to post their satirical advice online for ex-pats wanting to blend in: “never drive more than 500m without using your horn”, “never arrive early. In fact, aim for twenty minutes late”.

The self-deprecating humour disguises serious questions about Lebanese identity. I would hardly be rich if I had a Lebanese pound for each time someone has told me “I’m not Arab, I’m Lebanese”, but you get the idea.

Since the end of its devastating civil war in 1990, Lebanon’s capital has been rebuilt in the image of a modern European city: malls, skyscrapers, luxury hotels and supermarket chains abound as a result of the controversial ‘Solidere’ regeneration project. Only the northern party districts of Gemmayze and Mar Michael retain a sense of the traditional, ‘old’ Beirut. And along with this physical development is the widespread belief that the Lebanese identity is European.

This strong sense of identity manifests itself in language too. Lebanese dialect uses just about as many English and French words as it does Arabic, and you’re just as likely to hear ‘Sorry’ and ‘Merci’ being used on the streets as the common Arabic invocation ‘Al-hamdillilah’. Dress codes in Beirut’s liberal downtown districts often take more from Manhattan than Muscat.

Yet while Beirut’s post-war built environment evokes those of Paris and London, its state structures and governance remain firmly rooted in the old world. With no government since February 2013, democracy is in limbo.

As Iranian Hezbollah involvement in Syria divides the country along sectarian lines yet again, uncertainty is set to remain. Formation of a Cabinet any time soon looks impossible, and May’s general elections feel more like an opportunity for radical groups to seize power than an exercise in democracy.

The impact on the capital’s residents is clear. There have been eight bombs in the last six weeks, and no-one is under any impression that the explosions will stop any time soon. All the while, the underlying dynamics of future destabilisation are more and more visible: spill over from the Syrian crisis is pushing more and more people over the border and into Beirut’s refugee camps, or onto the streets.

Lebanon has some tricky questions to address about democracy

How far attitudes towards this potential future crisis are in line with those of contemporary Europe is difficult to say. Any taxi driver can and will rant until hoarse about the treatment of Palestinians in Israel, and yet most Lebanese people dismiss Syrian toddlers begging on the streets with a wave of the hand, and easily ignore migrant workers picking through bins without a thought for this strange discrepancy in behaviour and attitude.

Whether Lebanon wants to emulate members of the EU – and perhaps one day join itself – is hard to say. Being Lebanese, not Arabic, does not imply adopting all aspects of European culture. Yet as the trial into the assassination of Lebanon’s controversial former Prime Minister Rafiq Hariri continues at The Hague, it’s clear that Lebanon has some tricky questions to address about democracy, equality, and human rights, before its capital can truly live up to its nickname of the Paris of the Middle East.

Photograph: Ramseynasser