Leaving the Left Behind

By Henri Porritt

I was born and raised in Hartlepool, a town famous for its seaside location, its mythical monkeys, and most recently – for ranking third in the Indices of Deprivation 2025 report. Trailing Middlesbrough and Birmingham, my hometown rounds out the podium of local authorities with the highest proportion of the most deprived neighbourhoods. With it, it rounds out a story about my home, and places like it, that I am long familiar with. 

For context, the Indices of Deprivation is a report commissioned by the Ministry of Housing, Communities, and Local Government that seeks to quantify the various levels of deprivation in local communities through analysing elements such as health, education and crime. By ranking each neighbourhood in this way, a map is constructed, with clusters of deep blue signalling inequality. Looking at this map, dotted with bruises of deprivation, the reality of regional divide is clear. Year on year, the same towns and cities pop up again – Middlesbrough, Birmingham, Hartlepool, Blackpool – and yet no changes emerge. 

But with this, a question does emerge: why? And more importantly to me, what is the impact on these communities? 

Most of the towns that are highlighted in the report tell a similar story. Predominantly northern, and almost all post-industrial, the recent history bears an all-too-similar slant. The decline of British industry, manufacturing, shipbuilding, mining, that marked the 20th century, is still a tangible weight upon the towns. Whether they are coastal hubs, now aimlessly sitting with no ships to build or tourists to receive, or pit-towns, sprawled around a now closed-up-wound, they exist in the memory of something that is now gone. Physically, the buildings stand, but their spirits are in the past. 

The fundamental truth is that while the train station may brag about its brand new platform, and the millions spent on it, people are still only ever passing through. 

The initial economic impact of such de-industrialisation is common sense, the closing down of industry brings with it an immediate loss of jobs, an immediate drop in income, an immediate drop in the local economy, and rises of poverty and unemployment. More insidious side effects grow alongside, the impact on mental health that comes with financial instability, the physical health concerns brought with it – the loss of community that a shared identity and workplace provide. 

Discussing this, my position is not one of objectivity. I lived in the centre of Hartlepool for my entire living memory, I grew up in a town that had been cored out. My neighbourhood, the report informs me, has more deprived living conditions than 97% of the country, our health prospects standing at worse than 95%. I love my town, and it runs in my veins. The culture and history that makes me who I am is infused into the streets. I can walk a 10 minute loop that takes me to the houses that my grandmother, my father, and I all grew up in. But in that time, I remain in an area with more deprivation than 85% of the country.

It’s through these eyes, that it is obvious to me that it isn’t just the impact of de-industrialisation that scars my town and the others like it. Being raised through the Conservative government’s onslaught of austerity politics, it isn’t a secret that it was these vulnerable towns that were hit the hardest. Hospitals closed in areas already struck with poor health, benefits cut to families already running out of prospects. Shops shuttered, and anti-universal credit graffiti sprung up in their place. 

None of this is new information to the Government. Disastrous attempts at ‘levelling-up’ have desperately tried to present these gaps, this inequality, as something in control, something that can be bridged by regeneration. But the fundamental truth is that while the train station may brag about its brand new platform, and the millions spent on it, people are still only ever passing through. 

The damage to these areas is now cultural. Living there, I have only known success in one way – leaving. I can love my town, but to stay there would be seen as a personal tragedy and a failing of my potential. The energy has shifted, long have we passed trying to plug leaking holes and press on, now we have resigned to sending people away from the sinking ship. The children who are able to make it through elevated poverty and sub-standard education, leave. Those who can’t, never will. 

It hurts, more than anything, to see places like Hartlepool fall into this. The history and culture and community infused into each of these towns is staggering, but in the absence of targeted funding, of a reversal of austerity, of new industry to fill in the gaps; it is hard to see anything changing. Unfortunately, those left to suffer the consequences are the most vulnerable: the youngest, the oldest, and the sickest. We owe a debt to these towns, that isn’t getting paid. 

In the meantime, I will imagine moving home – to a neighbourhood that isn’t dyed so deep blue.

Image by Paul Buckingham via Wikimedia Commons.