Laughing through the pain
By Martin Docherty
Juliet: “What’s wrong, Romeo?”
Romeo: “Mercutio is dead!” [exit stage left, in obvious distress]
—
Romeo: “My mum thinks that ‘lol’ means lots of love”
Juliet: “Why is that a problem?”
Romeo: “She just texted me: ‘Mercutio’s dead, lol”
—
Arguing that either tragedy or comedy have objective artistic merit over the other is quite frankly ridiculous, reductive and easy to rebut. Rather than making such an un-nuanced claim, it would be more correct to state that the genres can both be used to impact the reader in different, but not superior or inferior ways. But that isn’t quite as catchy as a subheading for this article.
Attempting to pit the two genres against each other, like a mourner and a stand-up comedian in a gladiator fight, is inherently flawed. Nevertheless, although I strongly disagree with the comparative evaluation, it is clear to see why it arises. In arguably the first ever piece of literary criticism, Aristotle’s Poetics, the philosopher outlines the different conventions which he believes good drama should adhere to, and the two genres have several distinct similarities. Both involve the repeated “error” of some form of hero and the reliance on catharsis, a process of releasing previously repressed emotions. Without sounding too much like a pretentious English student, it is clear that tragedy and comedy have always addressed similar themes and topics, as they attempt to expose and explore what makes us human.
Generic differences can be found when you compare works like the Shakespearean tragedy Macbeth, and Ben Jonson’s satiric comedy Volpone, (or ‘Sly Fox’ in Italian). Macbeth is a tragic narrative documenting how lust for power can cause the downfall of anyone infected by it. The only time a sadder story has been told about Scotland is when Alex Salmond was elected First Minister. In contrast, Volpone makes a mockery of stereotypical old Italian men, condemning their money-hoarding and fetishisation of wealth. Jonson’s wicked sense of humour in Volpone is at times even sneakier and subtler than the ‘Fox’ for which the work was named. The texts are linked by a common theme – the exploration of human greed, and a recognition of the hubris that comes from the inherent lust for something more.
But the question remains, does one have more artistic merit than the other? They’re both very skilful considerations of similar ideas, but the approach taken is so different that it’s inherently fallacious to claim one is superior to the other. It’s a false equivalence. The types of catharsis provided by the works are too distinct to draw comparative evaluation between the genres; tragic catharsis reflects and mimics the emotions and sentiments of the characters, whereas comedic catharsis pokes fun at those emotions, sentiments and actions. Yes, we can compare individual works across the genres, and how well they achieve what they intended to, but the extrapolation of that to an entire genre is inescapably reductionist, and therefore should not be done.
As we reach our cathartic climax of this article (a comedy if you like my jokes, a tragedy if not), it is also worth considering what strengths both genres contain when it comes to dramatization. Generally speaking, it could be said that tragic catharsis lends itself better to more sensitive themes, as it is hard to conceive of a comedy being able to easily address psychological issues, such as PTSD, abuse, rape or torture. For instance, whilst Volpone contains a scene of attempted rape, it specifically plays it off as a negative error of the comedic (but very flawed) protagonist, and the joke around it isn’t nearly as emotive an exploration of the consequences as a tragedy might offer.
On the other hand, comedy is often better suited to meta-drama, and can use its jokes and conventions to comment on the nature of the medium. Comedy can therefore form a way through which playwrights and actors address their own art form, and inadvertently reach a closer level of intimacy with their audience, which is an act of artistic merit in itself. But this, like the catharsis brought about by tragedy, is simply one aspect of why the genres are different, but nevertheless equally rich with artistic merit.
To paraphrase Hamlet:
HAMLET: To be, or not to be–that is the question:
Whether ’tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of ridiculous comparisons.
If you want to write for Palatinate Stage then why not join our Facebook group for regular content calls.
Photo credit: Castle Theatre Company; Theodore Holt-Bailey as Hamlet in ‘Hamlet’
