Labour’s broadband plan: connected thinking
By Alex Marsh
It was perhaps no surprise when Telecoms firms reacted with dismay to Labour’s announcement last week that they would aim to provide free full-fibre broadband to every UK household through the nationalisation of Openreach, BT’s broadband division.
‘These proposals would be a disaster for the telecoms sector and the customers that it serves,’ declared the chief executive of TechUK, Julian David.
There is no doubt that this proposal is radical – only Australia has tried something similar, and admittedly with varying success. However, such apocalyptic hyperbole loses all rhetorical value when it is rolled out every time Labour announces a proposal to re-write the rules of the economy.
It is clear from their reaction that UK Telecoms firms fail to understand that they cannot systematically underinvest in the UK’s broadband capability and still expect to maintain their control over the network.
Furthermore, patronising Labour about its obligation to the customer appears disingenuous at best, as Openreach has been repeatedly criticised by the watchdog Ofcom for foot-dragging over the slow pace of fibre optic roll-out. As a result, the UK has been ranked 35th of the 37 OECD members reporting their percentage of fibre connections in total broadband.
A Labour government could hardly do much worse.
Part of the problem lies in the fact that the high infrastructural costs of installing fibre optic cables naturally create a virtual monopoly for broadband. This is most apparent in rural areas, where 93% of premises only have the option of superfast broadband from one provider. Openreach has been exposed to minimal competition as a result, giving them no incentive to ramp up investment in the UK’s broadband network, benefiting their shareholders far more than the customers they claim to serve.
Some will understandably question the affordability of Labour’s proposal. Nationalisation requires an initial upfront cost in compensation and estimates for the market value of Openreach range between £13.5 billion and £20 billion. There would then be the additional cost of building the new fibre network, something Labour claims would cost £20 billion, although BT’s chief executive believes the figure could be nearly double that.
Labour maintain that much of the bill would be footed through the taxation of large tech corporations such as Amazon and Google, and many experts claim that the policy does make sound financial sense, as savings would be made by eliminating the need for a shareholder dividend.
Ultimately, however, in a country which is by all measures one of the richest in the world, nobody can seriously claim that the policy is beyond the realm of affordability. The debate should therefore focus on the necessity of such a policy.
In modern Britain it has become almost impossible to fully access educational resources or apply for jobs without internet connectivity.
An expensive service naturally hits poorer communities harder, and it is clear to see that denying everyone equal access to full-fibre broadband will only serve to pre-determine the winners and losers in an increasingly competitive and technologically dependent economy.
A deficient broadband service therefore poses a bipartite problem for policymakers. On the one hand, a failure to invest in improving our broadband capability risks Britain falling behind the rest of the world in this area. On the other hand, a failure to cut costs for the average consumer risks pricing out the most disadvantaged in our society, ultimately making a mockery of our pretences at social mobility.
So, whilst the Prime Minister can deride Labour’s policy as a ‘crazed communist scheme’, the British people should not be so readily dismissive. We need a radical rethink of how broadband is provided in this country, and Labour might just have found the solution.
Image by Alwyn Ladell via Creative Commons.
