Kobane: a town between two worlds
The battle for Kobane between ISIS and the Kurdish Peshmerga forces (supported by the U.S. led coalition’s airstrikes) continues.
After ISIS’s very rapid territory conquest during summer, Kobane – an ethnically Kurdish Syrian town bordering Turkey – was encircled by the radical Jihadist group.
It has been over a month since the world started to watch Kobane’s – at the beginning, hopeless – fight. Obviously, this town, the third biggest Kurdish town in Syria, was not the only place where fighting was going on.
Whilst the world witnessed ISIS’s mass executions and civil massacres; how Yazidis had been pitilessly targeted, their women enslaved and abused; Kobane has taken the limelight as a microcosm for the region – one town, isolated and completely encircled by ISIS and an ‘impassable’ wall (according to the international media) to the north.
And as the days stretched on the world feared that, should Kobane fall after such a stubborn fight, ISIS would have been very, very cruel.
This was when the international community pressured Turkey to take action.
Indeed, Turkey had massed troops at its border with Kobane and Turkish soldiers were watching the fight going on from the hills at the other side of the invisible line.
The pressure was also domestic. Many families in Turkish towns and villages bordering the area had relatives or acquaintances in Kobane. Many Turkish citizens from Kurdish ethnicity protested.
Tensions failed to be abated, when clashes between supporters of the Kurdish Workers’ Party (PKK) and supporters of Hüda-Par, an Islamic radical party and Turkish branch of the Hezbollah, led to the deaths of over 30 people from both sides.
For many, it seemed that Turkey ought to leave aside its political and geopolitical strategies and interests and help Kobane: this was presented as a human/moral duty.
But what was not emphasized in the western media was the fact that the vast majority of Kobane’s inhabitants (the civilians) had fled to Turkey at the beginning of the fights; those remaining were mainly fighters who chose to stay behind.
Turkey has accomplished its humanitarian duty, firstly, by welcoming so far between 150,000 and 200,000 thousand Kurdish Syrians coming from Kobane, and secondly, by treating wounded Kurdish soldiers.
Yet, the international community asked for more: Turkey was pressured to undertake a territorial military operation, creating a corridor for weapons and fighters destined for Kobane.
Demands were not of a humanitarian dimension anymore, but political and strategic.
The demand for this intervention was both illegitimate and unreasonable. It was illegitimate because neither Turkey, nor the Peshmerga, wanted a Turkish military intervention in the region; it was illegitimate because Turkish troops would then enter Syria without the consent of the Syrian State (this is important international law-wise; the legitimacy of the current Syrian government is another question).
Furthermore, it was completely unreasonable.
First of all, no one ought to and should expect Turkey to engage ISIS alone on Syrian soil: there is a huge difference between airstrikes and territorial engagement. Many claimed that it was in Turkey’s own interest to intervene because if Kobane were to fall, Turkey would have ISIS as a neighbour along a huge part of its south eastern border.
There is a difference between directly attacking ISIS, engaging with it, even becoming one of its primary targets, and sharing a border with it.
Furthermore, Turkey sees Kobane as the fight for two enemy forces: the Kurdish Peshmerga (tightly linked to the PKK, responsible for the deaths of 30,000 people since the 1980s) and ISIS for Turkey.
The good news for Kobane is that Turkey has changed its attitude towards this in the last week: following a phone call between the Presidents of Turkey and of the United States, American aircrafts have begun dropping aid supplies and arms to Kurdish forces in Kobane on Monday, while Turkey has officially announced that it was to allow a safety corridor to Peshmerga fighters so that they could reach Kobane and take part in the fight.
The geopolitical issues in the area are far too complex for simple solutions such as a Turkish military action.
Turkey has also its own priorities, such as not sinking into the chaotic state of warfare that has taken over in the region, protecting the unity of the country and ensuring the safety of its citizens at home.
It has also succeeded in playing a key humanitarian role by welcoming hundreds of thousands of refugees from the region; we should remember that such a large number of refugees constitutes an additional struggle for Turkey which will last well into the future and take up valuable resources and funds.
Illustration: Patrick Mason

