Kemi at conference: The Conservatives at a crossroads?
By Valentino Dawson
It could be fairly argued that the British Conservative Party has been the most successful political party of all time. However, five years, three Tory Prime Ministers and one landslide election defeat later, this historic political powerhouse could be in its twilight. The mood at this year’s Conservative Party Conference in Manchester reflected that uneasy reality: a party desperately attempting to project confidence and renewal, yet facing apathy in its own ranks.
Leaving the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), ÂŁ50 billion worth of proposed spending cuts and the surprise commitment to abolish stamp duty formed the backbone of a flurry of policy announcements from leader Kemi Badenoch and her shadow Cabinet. Nevertheless, behind the slogans of “freedom,” “growth,” and “reform,” there was an undeniable sense that the party – now deep in opposition – is struggling to reignite belief in its economic credibility and political identity. Empty seats at keynote addresses, including Shadow Chancellor Sir Mel Stride’s, told a story as powerfully as any speech; one of low morale, desperation to be heard, and existential uncertainty.
”There was an undeniable sense that the party – now deep in opposition – is struggling to reignite belief in its economic credibility and political identity”
Badenoch’s keynote speech sought to reframe the Conservatives as the “party of fiscal responsibility”. Chief among her pledges was a vow to abolish stamp duty on owner-occupied homes, aiming to revive the property market and appeal to younger voters priced out of home ownership. The estimated £9 billion revenue loss, she claimed, would be covered by deep cuts across welfare, foreign aid, and civil service administration, totaling around £50 billion over five years. Furthermore, she committed to a fiscal “golden rule” whereby at least half of any savings from future spending cuts would go towards reducing the deficit, which is currently forecasted to be £60 billion for 2024-25. Badenoch also unsurprisingly preached for the reversal of certain recent tax increases under Labour, including the VAT on private schools and inheritance tax on farms, in a bid to appeal to the party’s historic voter base.
Beyond this, a general shift was seen towards the more radical right wing policies, as the Tory leader exclaimed: “It is that whole system which we need to reform”. This included a repeal of the Human Rights Act, establishing a formal British immigration force, intensifying police stop and search powers, and scrapping net-zero regulations in favour of resuming North Sea oil drilling.
The strong undertones of Thatcherism in this policy blitz does not go unnoticed, especially given the highly publicised parties celebrating the 100th anniversary of the Iron Lady’s birth. Some analysts described it as a “sharp rightward tilt,” in a blatant bid to recapture disillusioned voters tempted by Reform UK, with The Guardian recently commenting on the battle to be heirs to Thatcher’s legacy. But is anyone listening to this ideological realignment?
The choreography of renewal in Manchester struggled to disguise a deeper malaise. Despite efforts to fill the venue for Badenoch’s keynote, rows of empty seats and muted applause suggested a party wrestling with fatigue and fading belief. Even Mel Stride’s economic address, which had been billed as the intellectual core of the conference, drew an eerily sparse audience. For many, the echoes of past crises still linger; memories of Truss’ market turmoil, inflation and uncosted tax cuts have left members wary of another round of fiscal adventurism.Â
”Rows of empty seats and muted applause suggested a party wrestling with fatigue and fading belief”
That uncertainty has been sharpened by the rise of Reform UK, whose populist energy and hardline rhetoric continue to siphon support from the Conservatives’ traditional base. In September alone, one sitting Conservative MP defected to Reform alongside former cabinet minister Nadine Dorries and 20 sitting Conservative councillors. Badenoch’s tougher stance on migration and sovereignty is widely seen as an attempt to blunt this threat, whilst critics warn it risks alienating moderates, potentially pushing voters towards Labour and the Liberal Democrats.
Behind the scenes, doubts persist over Badenoch’s leadership. Indicative of this, one delegate did openly declare support for her stewardship, if only to safeguard the party’s future, stating: “I think she should resign in 2028. Be a sacrificial lamb”. By extension, party insiders quietly discussed possible successors, most prominently Shadow Secretary of State for Justice Robert Jenrick, seen by moderates as a more pragmatic and electable alternative should the Conservatives’ polling stagnate. However, as things stand, it would appear Badenoch’s performance was enough to prolong her candidacy at least for the immediate future.
The future of the party itself however, remains uncertain. For now, the Manchester conference laid bare both the ambition and fragility of Badenoch’s project. The Conservatives may remain the most electorally resilient party in modern history, but this week, even their most loyal members seemed to sense that resilience being tested as never before. Will they go down with a fight?
Image: James Whatling CCHQ via Wikimedia Commons

Image: James Whatling CCHQ via Wikimedia Commons
