Keep your custard pies to yourself: attention-seeking charity is degrading

I’D LIKE TO clarify: I whole heartedly support DUCK. Durham can be proud to host one of the largest money-making charity organisations in the country. Last year, they raised almost £320,000 for local and international charities, and the lengths that some individuals go to make a difference is inspiring.

However, why is there always that sense of reluctance when those yellow buckets are thrust in our faces as we sit sipping a £3.30 brownie bomber in the college bar?

This is not comfortable subject matter. But I will presume that everyone can relate to that feeling of guilt as we hurry past Big Issue sellers on the street, ourselves laden with bags of shopping – are we being selfish, denying £1.50 to a homeless person, when we have just bought an overpriced tub of chocolate treats from Waitrose? Are we genuinely worried about our finances? Or is it just the frequent “intrusion” of charity in our everyday lives that renders us passive and unsympathetic?

Letitia Clark’s article in The Sanctuary concerning Big Issue sellers in Durham unexpectedly sparked controversy, yet I am puzzled as to how a few “innocent” jokes can cause more distress than the majority of students (sorry, Will Wilson) who will ignore the sellers in the street.

The fact is that charity is a taboo subject and can be used as an “excuse” for almost anything. If that infamous bucket does rattle your way – it doesn’t
matter who or what or why – the “good cause” is unquestioned and you are expected to cough up those coins.

Many colleges use one particularly ingenious idea: “custard” shaving foam pies which were sporadically shoved in people’s faces as they ate in the canteen throughout the week. Pay £2 and pie anyone you want. I admit I was on the receiving end. I hope I took it rather well, despite falling over while running out of the hall.

But my point is, we should be more aware of what goes on behind these somewhat ludicrously entertaining events and have a more concrete knowledge of whom we are supporting. Apart from DUCK’s website, the general lack of information concerning the actual charities is rather intriguing.

I’ve done my fair share of fundraising at university. I’ve climbed hills, slept on the street and done fun-runs for charity. I even applied to be part of a DUCK organised trip his summer. I was invited to an interview, which seemed to be going rather well until the last question: which fruit would you be and why? My response: a mango, because, em… and that was when I knew I’d blown it.

I asked myself afterwards why I had really wanted to travel to the other side of the world. The improvement of my CV and the benefit of an eye-opening experience were just as important to me as the personal need I felt to help the orphans. Nevertheless, if I had been accepted onto the trip, I genuinely hope I would have been able to make a positive contribution to the project. But would everyone?

Consider the infamous “Mr and Miss Fresher” competitions, slave auctions and shaving-foam-pie throwing: do the words “charity” and “exploitation” go hand in hand in competitive collegiate society? In the same way that corporate businesses such as KPMG will hand out free cupcakes next to the Student Union, DUCK knows that guaranteed entertainment and free goodies will always encourage students to dig deeper in their pockets: they are predictable marketing strategies that simultaneously entice us and insult our intelligence.

It would be gratifying to see an active yet more personal, dignified approach to fundraising in Durham.

Concerning the events named above, it could all be harmless fun – I’m not a complete cynic, I paid to get revenge on the person who asked to shove a shaving-foam pie in my face.

On the other hand, it could be attention-seekers reaping the free rewards. In the name of the good cause, of course.