Kate Middleton’s portrait: a glimpse of the future?
Even as The Duchess of Cambridge declared her first official portrait “Brilliant” at the National Portrait Gallery earlier this month, critics were dashing back to their desks to lambast the work of Paul Emsley, 65. With the revealing of the piece, Kate is inducted even further into the time honoured traditions of British royalty, but perhaps the real question here is whether or not this painting will alter her stance as the public’s new favourite royal (well, second to the dear old Queen that is).
Upon seeing the highly photo realistic painting my initial reaction was one of surprise, I have to admit that I hardly follow the affairs of our potential future monarch with as much tenacity as the royal correspondents rolled out for occasions such as this. This was a feeling quickly followed by mild guilt, as I tried to recall whether Kate actually looked that old, and a sudden fear that I’d lost track of the last ten years of my life. Thankfully for me, the art correspondents of a dozen newspapers were already up in arms about her somewhat ‘mature’ appearance, with only a handful of voices raised in Emsley’s defence.
Calling the photographs that appear in some of our newspapers and magazines today ‘realism’ has become a stretch of the imagination, so maybe it is only fitting that we are not used to seeing it in the media. Despite the painting’s apparent genre tag though, I can see what Mark Hudson of the Telegraph refers to as the ‘painful literalness’ of the work in the immaculately groomed hair which falls in auburn ringlets about her shoulders.
Emsley has translated an idea of refined, traditional beauty onto a royal known for her natural looks, which creates a grating combination of the two images. Hudson criticised Emsley for trying to appeal to the sense of beauty of a ‘man in the street’, although perhaps that was Emsley’s intention all along. After the vitriolic reception of such royal portraits as Lucian Freud’s brutal rendition of the Queen in 2001, it is understandable that an artist poised for such a commission would be interested in avoiding such backlash by appealing to as many people as possible.
Emsley is famous for his use of a reduced colour palette, which we can see here in the similarity between the greens he uses to shade her facial features and the tones seen in her neck tie and the background. This is most notably observed around the eyes and it is this effect that has encouraged some critics to condemn Emsley for ‘aging [Kate] needlessly’. I would recommend an interested reader to investigate some of Emsley’s other work for examples of this, as this is definitely not a representation of his best painting.
Kate’s plain dress and directed pose are a stark contrast to her usually active appearance in the media, giving her a very serious appearance despite the supressed smile. In all fairness, perhaps it is a relief for the Duchess to be cast in a mould traditionally considered to be respectable enough for a potential monarch. Compared to the last time pictures of her were circulated around the press, a run-of-the-mill royal portrait must be a welcome change.
Though perhaps this is where Emsley went wrong,. If he was attempting to create an image to be consumed mercilessly by the public then he ought to have looked no further than the sales figures for the late summer editions of Europe’s most scandalous celebrity magazines.
Realism can cause alarm when used in portraiture, partly from the fact that an artist’s technique will always alter a subject, creating an often disconcerting version of a familiar image. Part of the shock of the painting from a viewer’s perspective comes from seeing a young and active woman recast in such a formal setting. Her dark eyes and taut lips may well make her look older than she appears to be in the magazines, but this is photo realism and it’s not supposed to be over-produced.
Rather than seeing the Duchess glossily represented in this minute’s latest fashionable outfit, or reclining on a sparkling Mediterranean beach, we are given an eerie glimpse of an older figure from a possible future, one we are not really ready for.
The Kate in Emsley’s painting looks as though she could be a queen. The only problem is that she is not one quite yet.

