Junior Doctors’ contracts: an unfair deal

22277627881_c9b5d66537_k

By Alex MacDonald

If you have kept an eye on the news over the last month you will no doubt be aware of the changes to be imposed on junior doctors’ contracts by the Department of Health as well as the objection of junior doctors to these changes. The proposed changes initially focused on a reduction in the number of hours of the week counted as unsocial and the removal of pay banding within those unsociable hours, meaning increased pay for those working during the night. As well as this the government intended to remove payments which were used to encourage doctors into those areas of medicine with a shortage of doctors, such as General Practice.

These changes are argued by the government to have little impact on the actual average take home pay of junior doctors, due to their proposed increase of the standard salary. This issue is a moot point as it will be likely to vary from doctor to doctor depending on their working hours. However, it is not particularly this that the doctors’ unions have taken issue with, but rather the changes in hours which now make a ninety-hour week ‘sociable’ and increase the likelihood of doctors working longer hours due to the negligible cost. Claiming that doctors don’t work weekends is simply a lie, with most juniors working for one in every two. Such a smear is undoubtedly the intention of the government as they attempt to introduce a ‘24/7 NHS’. However, the resulting changes would put patient safety at risk with overtired, overworked staff. A 24/7 NHS can only be developed on the understanding of numerically more doctors being employed; we simply cannot expect the existing staff to work every hour of the week.

Interestingly however, the projected reduction in trainee GP pay of 40%, through the removal of additional payments, does not coincide with the fact that the country is currently suffering from an estimated shortfall of nearly 8,000 family doctors. Therefore, the ending of this ‘Recruitment and Retention Payment’ (RRP) has a large gap in its logic; it will see doctors take a huge pay cut when they begin their training for General Practice. Failing to see the importance of financial rewards for a doctor after years of rigorous training shows a worrying lack of foresight by our policy makers.

It is also perhaps pertinent to consider that these changes became widespread public news just as a new host of medical students headed off to university for their first year. It might be worth considering the number who may feel that their medical future will lie outside the UK in more fruitful pastures. The GMC (General Medical Council) received 1,664 requests for certificates of Current Professional Status (CCPS) in three days alone last month. These are certifications used to apply for jobs abroad. Pay in countries such as the USA and Australia can sometimes be more than double that in UK for doing the same job. This is clearly a worrying time for our NHS.

However, I would suggest that this issue is about more than just junior doctor pay. These disputes belie how truly unmanageable the NHS has become. Increased pressure on all services coupled with the ever pressing need to reduce public expenditure and control the continued expansion of the publicly funded conglomerate have meant that many sacrifices have been made already across the NHS. Most doctors already work far more than their contracted hours in order to deliver the service their patients need. In addition, the system as we know it is crumbling with GP practices closing everywhere and doctors fleeing the country. Subsequently, vast sums need to be invested in the service if we are to keep up with the ever expanding and aging population. This doesn’t mean a few hundred million pounds in reorganization, but a radical investment in capacity at certain levels – particularly primary and A&E care. The problem of course becomes all the more pressing when considering current fiscal pressures.

In light of this, what we require is a completely new attitude towards healthcare in this country. We must understand that healthcare costs vast sums of money, requires the brightest, hardest working minds and that those individuals do deserve financial rewards. We also need to understand our own fiscal limitations and perhaps move to a system in which ‘free at the point of need’ is not the ultimate end goal. Our end goal should be to supply quality healthcare to those in need of it – whether or not it is entirely free is another issue. In Ireland the majority of the population pay up to sixty euros to visit a GP or A&E, while those with poorer heath and lack of financial resources do not. I am not suggesting that any fee should be that high – ten pounds may suffice – but a scheme such as this would reduce pressure on primary care and A&E from unnecessary visits and also raise huge revenue which could be put into maintaining the service. These are controversial suggestions (although most of us already pay for prescriptions and dental care), but they will be necessary if we are to continue to maintain a high quality National Health Service where the best minds are working to the best of their abilities.

Photograph: Rohin Francis via Flickr