Jules Bianchi: an unnecessary disaster

By Will Moulton

Formula_one

 

The 2014 Japanese Formula 1 Grand Prix won’t be remembered for how wet it was. It won’t be remembered for Lewis Hamilton’s masterful victory that extended his World Championship lead over team-mate Nico Rosberg. What it will be remembered for, however, is Jules Bianchi’s horrible accident that has left him fighting for his life. As the rain increased, Bianchi spun off the track and into the back of a recovery vehicle that was picking up the stricken car of Adrian Sutil, who had done exactly the same just a lap earlier. The worst part of all this? The accident was entirely preventable.

Formula 1 is a dangerous sport and the risks are high, especially with the combination of cars capable of over 200mph whilst having open cockpits. The statistics also back this up, with 30 drivers dying and many more suffering many serious injuries since the inaugural World Championship in 1950 . It is almost an accepted norm that the drivers are potentially risking their lives to do something they love and entertain the general public; what is unacceptable, though, is that improvements in safety are more often reactive than proactive.

It can be argued that Bianchi was extremely unlucky – a foot or so to his right and he would have missed the recovery truck completely and just slid into the tyre barrier; but he didn’t and right now he is fighting for his life in hospital. The marshalls, however, cannot be blamed for the incident – they were just doing what they were told and trying to remove Sutil’s car as quickly as possible. The fault here lies with the regulations; the recovery vehicle should not have been allowed onto the circuit until the rest of the drivers were under the control of the safety car, something the teams, drivers and fans alike are now calling for.

A very similar situation was seen at the European Grand Prix in 2007, when seven cars spun off at the end of a high speed straight after a lot of rain fell in a short space of time. The recovery truck tried to come out that day too, but the marshalls sensibly stopped as the cars were flying off one after the other. Their quick thinking almost undoubtedly stopped a serious injury that day, yet no lessons were learned – but why not? Most tracks have long, fast straights which end with a corner that requires rapid deceleration which means cars are likely to lose control in the rain due to their low downforce. The corner that both Sutil and Bianchi crashed at is normally taken flat out in the dry and even in the wet the cars still travel round it at around 150mph. It should have been common sense that the recovery truck shouldn’t have been allowed out until the safety car had control of the race – if that had happened, Bianchi may still have lost control but would only have hit the tyre wall only and almost certainly been ok.

Another measure being requested is that the cockpits become enclosed. I’m not sure, however, how beneficial this would be. At the speed he was travelling and with the car being so low, I don’t think it would have made much of a difference. He may not be so seriously injured, but it’s likely his head would have still struck the truck in some way.

The majority of the deaths in F1 have been down to the brain being damaged as a result of the head being thrown around violently during a high velocity collision, not because it struck something. The head is now extremely well protected – the cockpits are now built to absorb as much energy as possible, the roll-over bar above the driver has been raised to stop their head from hitting the floor if the car overturns and a HANS (head and neck safety) device has been introduced to stop the drivers’ heads from being thrown around. As a result, these injuries are now extremely rare.

Why, though, has it taken an incident such as this to get these ideas into the public domain? Enclosed cockpits have actually been in the process of development for a number of years now, yet this has only become common knowledge as a result of a serious and potentially fatal incident. It’s unacceptable that, in a world that has gone crazy for health and safety, the drivers are still not being protected as much as they should be.

I really hope that the FIA learn from this and recognise they need to prevent these injuries from happening at all rather than reacting to one or two incidents. More importantly though, let’s hope that Bianchi not just survives but that, one day, we’ll see him driving a racing car again.

Photograph: Wikipedia