JCR levy: how much and what for?

by Sam Lipman
The first term of a new year is always wrought with expenses; accommodation, tuition fees, new books. Amongst these charges is the college Junior Common Room (JCR) levy, an expense paid unquestioningly by most, at a time where bank account balances make a rapid transition into exponential decline and students are forced to become uncomfortably acquainted with the question: where did all the money go?
The JCR is the social hub of each of the University’s fifteen undergraduate colleges. Financed by student contribution each year, it invests into college formals and events, sports, societies, as well as welfare and facilities, including bars, common rooms, computer rooms and libraries.
Each college has its own structure, its own way of functioning, so it should come as no surprise that each college JCR levy comes at a different cost.
When considering the basic levy, there is a whopping £71 between the highest charge of £141 per three-year course at Grey College and the lowest charge of £70 at John Snow College, which works out at more than 100% cost increase on Grey’s part.
However, as always is the case with finance, the breakdown of overall JCR charges isn’t so black and white. John Snow’s JCR subscription costs £23.33 each year, but for second and third year livers-out, there is an additional charge of £10 (+£5 bottle of wine) per formal and men’s football adds another £50 to the bill. St. John’s on the other hand charges a £30 levy each year, but this includes fresher week costs, a weekly formal and college facilities.
On questioning Grey’s costs, as well as the additional fresher week rate of £20 and only two free formals each year, a result of the £51 association fee rather than the JCR levy, President Josh Turner commented: “as a JCR we pride ourself on the renowned and impressive range of social events we are able to put on for our students, including the largest fireworks display in the North East.
“Every penny received goes back into the student experience. We run the JCR ourselves as an independent charity – students working for students, and are proud of the work we do.”
Hatfield is another costly college, with a JCR levy of £120 and it would appear students are saving £21 within this JCR in comparison to what would seem to be the highest charging JCR at Grey. Except, when Hatfield’s levy is put into context with the £50 sports and societies fee as well as the £36 library and computing charge, which are included within Grey College’s levy, the total cost of being a member of Hatfield College with the ability to use all facilities totals £206 (excluding charity and association charges, including twice-weekly free formals for livers-in).
When compared with Van Mildert’s modest levy of £35 per year, which includes all sports, societies and facilities, the question remains to be asked, why is there such a noticeable cost discrepancy? Hatfield JCR President was unavailable for comment.
Josephine Butler’s levy, when incorporated with the use of all facilities, totals £150 and suddenly Grey is knocked well and truly off the top slot for most costly JCR. Similarly Trevelyan’s, with charges for JCR membership and the use of all facilities, as well as an extra cost for their college day, (also included in Grey’s levy), amounts to £137.50 throughout a three-year degree.
Having spoken to DSU President Mike King, it seems that each college receives an annual grant from the university. On the whole, the money subsidises any sabbatical officers working for the college JCR. Despite the absence of sabbatical officers in Trevelyan College, it still has one of the highest charging JCR levies. Where is the grant going?
The answer can be found in the college accounts; in comparison with other colleges, like Van Mildert, Trevelyan’s bar and events do not make a profit, therefore requiring excess contributions to fund college facilities, events and activities.
Most colleges fall within a bracket of £75-£130 JCR charges for a standard degree course, including facilities, welfare, sports and societies. Regardless of independency from the university, it is largely determined by the state of college finances and is therefore up to college discretion as to what the JCR costs will be and how they will be distributed.
St. Mary’s JCR president, Amy Annette, said: “We fund three course formals, sports kit, and other activities throughout the year meaning that, I believe, students get value for money and we have a number of funds to make sure that any student with financial difficulty is not precluded from any activity.”
It is possible to opt out of the JCR levy and ‘pay as you go’ for college formals and events, although this could end up working out more expensive than paying the original cost. College association fees must be paid regardless, a charge which some colleges, such as John Snow, do not have. Former Business graduate from George Stephenson College said: “I thought it might be worth doing but I never have yet.” This questions whether the alumni and trust association charges should also be obligatory.
Ultimately, college levees are put back into student members and it is subjective as to how much benefit a student can receive from it. Marta Blaszczynska of Grey College feels: “The college levees have been used in a good way and I know that the money goes towards things that I can get a lot out of.
“I can understand that some people who don’t like participating in college life feel that they shouldn’t pay towards it but my personal experience has been nothing but positive.”
