Jacinda Ardern’s resignation: courageous or yielding?
By Zarah Drummond
The great outpouring of support for Jacinda Ardern this past week marks her widespread impact as a leader adored by many beyond her nation’s borders. Ardern first attracted significant international attention as the country’s youngest leader in 150 years. When she had a baby in office and brought her newly born daughter to the floor at the United Nations she was portrayed as something of a feminist icon for juggling such a politically demanding career with motherhood. Nevertheless, reactions to her departure reflect an interesting array of interpretations of her time in office.
Women have often been plagued by patriarchal expectations that they cannot embody the ‘true’ masculine traits of leadership: decisiveness, confidence, an ability to make ‘tough’ decisions. Yet once female leaders embody such traits, they are labelled cold- hearted, unlikeable and ‘bossy.’ Moreover, Toril Aalberg and Andres Todal Jenssen’s research ‘Gender Stereotyping of Political Candidates’ shows that women are more likely to be asked how they will balance their careers with domestic-life and childcare than their male counterparts. Additionally, women’s private life get more media coverage and their appearance is highly scrutinised by the press, namely the misogyny directed at Hilary Clinton during the 2016 election. Such circumstances have long disincentivised many women from a political profession. Thus, like many before her, Ardern had to contend with sexist lines of questioning such as in 2017 when she was asked if a Prime Minister should be allowed maternity leave. More recently, when meeting Finnish Prime Minister Sanna Marin, both leaders were asked if they were meeting because they were “similar in age and have got a lot of common stuff there”.
The question is how did Ardern manage to avoid sexist labels ascribed to her while in office? How did she become famous for inspiring ‘feminine’ leadership in contrast to female leaders before her? Sheer political success may be the answer. From her decisive handling of the Christchurch terrorist attack to her careful management of the coronavirus pandemic, it’s no surprise personal attacks have less sting when political success remains high. Moreover, her unique leadership style and political honesty has bolstered her popularity. Her emotional intelligence and willingness to engage with voters in a down to earth manner has served to build a sense of trust that politicians usually struggle to create. Her advocacy for kindness and empathy contrasts heavily with the hallmarks we see in the populist ‘strongman’ leaders like Putin, Trump, or Bolsonaro. Finally, her willingness to admit self-doubt has humanised her to voters and begun to break the taboo that leaders should always be 100% confident in their own political decisions.
Women have often been plagued with patriarchal expectations
Nonetheless, part of the reason Ardern has received more favourable media attention is undoubtedly due to certain social biases. Her youth and status as a white woman prevents her from receiving cruel criticism levelled at older women like Clinton or women of colour like Diane Abbot. Her heterosexual relationship and position as a mother has no doubt reassured those suspicious of her ‘feminine qualities’ that she retains certain gender roles. Thus she has been saved from the criticism directed at single or childless female politicians, such as Julia Gillard who was told her decision to remain “deliberately barren” proved she was an unempathetic leader. Thus, while we should commend Ardern’s more humane and a less masculine form of leadership, we should not ignore the benefits of her compliance with received notions of womanhood.
It was inevitable that some pessimistic journalistic commentaries would condescendingly read Ardern’s exit as the final proof she had to face up to the restrictions imposed on her by her gender. The same publications that once celebrated her achievements as a woman now argue she maybe wasn’t that exceptional after all. The BBC came under fire for its headline: “Jacinda Ardern resignation: Can women really have it all?” condescendingly implying that Ardern’s departure was a result of her trying to juggle more roles that any woman is capable of. Fortunately, the BBC retracted the headline, but it raises the question of whether high achieving women suffer from increased gender bias once they leave office and the glamour of their ‘exceptionalism’ fades.
If anything, Ardern’s reflection that she no longer has ‘enough left in the tank’ should not be taken as caving to the calls of motherhood. Instead, it should be seen as a courageous decision by a well-established leader to hand the reins over to someone else with more dedication to give. If only other political leaders were as self-aware and less concerned with their political legacy, we might have more selfless and truly democratic leadership.
Image credit: Prachatai via Flickr

