It’s time to switch it up: Tate Modern’s New Build
By Jane Simpkiss
Over the summer, one of my best friends and I took a trip to Berlin. As someone interested in art, a trip to the Hamburger Bahnhof (one of Berlin’s main art galleries) was naturally on the agenda and thus we set off merrily on the U-Bahn for an enjoyable afternoon of surveying what promised to be some of the capital’s best modern art.
Some of it lived up to this promise. Some of it didn’t.
“Excuse me Madam,” said a kind but firm German voice to my friend, “But I think you’ll find you’re sitting on the art”
Cue extremely embarrassed and incredibly British apologies.
To be fair to my friend, we had been sightseeing all day and if she hadn’t confused the large marble cube for a bench first, I wouldn’t have been far behind.
My friend apologised saying that she could never have imagined that what she sat on was art.
“I could have made that!” or “A child could have made that” are phrases that you often hear echoing through art galleries and, especially when viewing modern or conceptual art, the question of whether something is or is not art is inescapable.
I found myself mulling this question over in my head when recently visiting the new Switch building at Tate Modern.
I found much of the art in the new galleries uninteresting and boring. A large gold disc with some dirty plastic piping sticking out of it; some cages on the floor with coloured bedding inside; few of the works held my attention past the first glance.
I found myself asking whether this was really art?
The mantel of conceptual art has made some artists lazy. The conceptual idea behind a piece of art is a vital component of its existence, especially in modern art, but art cannot and should not rest on an idea alone. Before reading the label that accompanies a piece of art or the exhibition guide book in your hand, you should have a natural, genuine response to the work in front of you- it doesn’t have to be earth shattering but you should feel something.
When approaching many of the pieces within the Tate’s new building, I felt nothing, no response. The concepts behind the bubble machine or the bedded cages may have been fantastic and perhaps I should have given them more of a chance, but I was so uninspired by the pieces that I failed to really take in what they were supposed to represent or allude to.
The Ai Wei-Wei tree sculpture on the way to the Switch building certainly inspired feeling, instilling a sense of stillness and silence in the passer-by and the Switch building itself was eye catching, its sharp geometric form complementing beautifully the view of the Shard in the distance. However, the permanent collection in Tate’s new wing failed to match up to its impressive exterior.

Image by John Lord via Flickr Creative Commons
At a time when arts funding is tight and thus attendance at exhibitions and museums is vital, big name galleries such as Tate Modern should be striving to show the best of modern art and proving its worth to the public. The work within our national museum’s should be the best on offer, ardent art lovers will not be dissuaded from attending institutions such as the Tate by one floor of bad art – I for one know that I will return. However, these are not the people we are trying to encourage. The Tate needs to be investing in art that wows the viewer.
A few months ago, some teenagers placed a pair of glasses on the floor of the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art to see the reactions of visitors. Many stopped to take photographs of this supposedly new exhibit in the gallery. Passers by and twitter users noted how the glasses could have been a comment on individuality and perception.
These glasses were not art; they lacked forethought and had no concept behind them, nor were they a spectacle (or spectacles) of outstanding craftsmanship. However, the fact that many believed them to be art shows the disservice that many galleries are doing to modern art. The art that is on display is boring or held up only by a limp conceptual idea; how different really is a pair of glasses placed on the floor by a passing visitor to the oversized plastic pink cube that sits pride of place in the Switch Building?
Tate Modern’s Collection is not without it’s gems. The old building contains some beautiful Jackson Pollock paintings and Alexander Calder Sculptures, the latter of which was the subject of a wonderful exhibition at the same gallery earlier this year. However, we must ask ourselves what was the point of constructing the Switch Building if it was only built to house middling works of modern art. Would the money not have been better spent enhancing the collection and proving modern art’s worth to the public?
The Switch Building is worth the visit for the space alone, it is an impressive addition to an already captivating landmark. However, despite Tate Modern’s facelift, the new building’s permanent collection is underwhelming, it’s time to switch it up and say no to mediocre modern art.
Photographs by Matt Brown and John Lord
