It’s time once again to discuss Scottish Independence
By Hazel Laurenson
The question of Scottish independence was certainly not resolved with the results of the 2014 referendum. When the details of the referendum were being negotiated, Nichola Sturgeon, SNP leader, orchestrated the question that would appear on the ballot paper to be advantageous to her.
By this, I am referring to how it is generally easier to persuade voters to opt for a positive, as opposed to a negative, option. The carefully constructed question that was put to the electorate – “Should Scotland be an independent country?” – thus reflects the astuteness of the key actors behind the current Scottish nationalist movement.
The neglection of Scottish issues by Westminster-centred parties has resulted in them becoming unprecedently weak in Scotland
The referendum’s outcome (55.3% for ‘No’, 44.7% for ‘Yes’) demonstrates the drastic oversimplifications inherent in the question “does Scotland even want to be part of the UK?”. This is one of numerous comments I have heard that illustrate the overwhelming misunderstanding, possessed by fellow students, that Scotland is a unanimous bloc.
I have found that many people in England view ‘Scottish people’ as a collective, unilateral force, whose political views align with the sentiment embodied by Mel Gibson dramatically shouting “Freedom!” Quite frankly, this baffles me. The reality is far more complex than this rather insulting two-dimensional image suggests.
At this point, I am conscious that I do not want to appear hypocritical: I am aware that not all English people take this view. Unfortunately, however, it is the stance of the majority of English-born students with whom I have recently discussed this issue. The question of independence has created, revealed, and magnified cleavages in Scottish communities in a way that many people south of Greta Green do not realise.
Independence is a complicated topic emotionally, as well as socially and economically. Its roots run deep, gaining nutrients from modern developments. The 1,617,989 voters who put a cross in the ‘Yes’ box in 2014 certainly did not do so based solely on romanticised notions of Scottish heritage. The momentum of contemporary Scottish nationalism is attributable to far more than invocations of idealistic memory.
There have been many recent eventualities that undermine the attractiveness of the United Kingdom for Scotland. The neglection of Scottish issues by Westminster-centred political parties has resulted in them becoming unprecedentedly weak in Scotland.
In the 2019 general election, Labour won one seat in Scotland. Ian Murray, the Labour MP who held his seat for Edinburgh South, is unique in his recognition and concern that the existence of Labour in Scotland is under threat. He has quite righty stated that “straddling those two constitutional issues [Scottish independence and Brexit] means we don’t stand up for anything”. It is largely the absence of a coherent alternative that compels swathes of the Scottish electorate to tick the nationalist box come voting day.
There have been many recent eventualities that undermine the attractiveness of the United Kingdom
Sturgeon campaigned in 2014 on the premise that it would be a “once in a generation” opportunity. Since then, she has changed her tact, demanding that her party’s domination last December warrants a second referendum. To me, this seems contradictory. Fortunately for Sturgeon, however, it is the sole tenuous argument she has made in a long time. Since moving to England, Sturgeon’s ethos has appealed to be in an unanticipated way. I have realised the true extent to which Scotland is regarded an extension of the United Kingdom, part of ‘outer Britain’, rather than a valued region.
Previously staunchly opposed to independence, I remain far from unequivocally swayed. However, recent domestic developments, in combination with public rhetoric and Sturgeon’s political authenticity, have led me to consider the future, and Scottish nationalism’s role in it, in a revised way.
Image credit: fw42 via Flickr
