It can’t go on like this, can it? Can a promoted side finally achieve Premier League survival?

By Luke Dufton

In the 2023/24 and 2024/25 Premier League campaigns, we had to wait until Gameweek 11 for all three promoted sides, who were eventually relegated, to record victories. It only took two rounds this season. Is this a turning point for promoted sides or is relegation inevitable?  

Apathy surrounded the final Premier League fixtures last season, partly due to an absent relegation fight. TV viewing figures dropped as each promoted side (Leicester, Ipswich, and Southampton) succumbed to the drop without much resistance. This emulated the disappointment of Luton, Burnley, and Sheffield United just one year prior.  

This disequilibrium prompted many analysts to immediately dismiss their replacements in the 2025/26 season. They mostly blamed instant relegations on the seismic void and structural disparities between England’s top two tiers.   

Whilst that argument holds substance, a nuanced overview of the past two seasons reveals that Leeds, Burnley, and Sunderland are not doomed. They have a realistic opportunity to survive through efficient business and tactical pragmatism, where the six before them faltered.   

Firstly, let’s look at the business failings of the previous six. Luton only spent approximately €25.9 million in the market. This was a calculated decision, prioritising investment in their prospective new stadium, yet it hindered their competitiveness. This is non-applicable for this year’s promoted outfits, who have spent over £350 million cumulatively on player acquisitions.  

A nuanced overview of the past two seasons reveal that Leeds, Burnley, and Sunderland are not doomed

In the 2023/24 season, Sheffield United were hampered by losing key players including Sander Berge, Iliman Ndiaye and a tranche of loans who were not adequately replaced. 

Similarly, Leicester lost Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, and were in managerial limbo following Enzo Maresca’s departure for Chelsea.   

Ipswich’s excessive recruitment in the Championship meant they overpaid for domestic talent, some of whom, like Jack Clarke, failed to adapt to Kieran McKenna’s brand of football. This represented little value for money as they went up against England’s strongest clubs. This strategy has largely been avoided this time.  

Alternatively, Burnley and Southampton stylistically failed to adapt to the league’s demands. Both managers (Vincent Kompany and Russell Martin) were unwilling to acclimatise their philosophies to combat the rigorous intensity and quality of the Premier League. This ended humiliatingly for both clubs, but is something that Daniel Farke, Scott Parker, and Regis Le Bris have steered away from.  

It is transparent that relegation is not inevitable; it is marked by individual context. Relegation can be avoided through calculated decisions and financial proficiency, which the previous six mismanaged. Yet, Leeds, a reinvented Burnley, and Sunderland have made promising steps.   

But who has done this most effectively? Unfortunately for Leeds and Burnley there are lingering similarities with the six relegated sides. Burnley lost key players including CJ Egan-Riley, and Josh Brownhill (who netted eighteen goals last season from midfield), and Leeds’ future appears tenuous, only exacerbated by a 5-0 defeat to Arsenal.   

That leaves Sunderland, who I believe are best positioned to achieve survival. The Wearsiders will still have to battle ferociously to extend their topflight stay, but they have deviated from past mistakes.  

Regis Le Bris, who has signed a new contract this summer, has often exhibited his willingness to change from a high press to a low block that can absorb pressure and break dangerously on the counterattack. This involves seamlessly shifting between a 4-4-2 and 4-1-4-1, which worked effectively in triumphs against West Ham and Brentford.   

Relegation can be avoided through calculated decisions and financial proficiency…

Sunderland’s recruitment team, fronted by long-term Sporting Director Kristjaan Speakman, and new ex-Roma Director of Football Florent Ghisolfi, have acted  methodically. They have re-negotiated crucial player’s contracts including Eliezer Mayenda and Trai Hume, extracted maximum value from the sales of non-fundamental players in Jobe Bellingham and Tommy Watson, and then used funds to spend more than £150 million on bolstering key areas of the squad.   

This overhaul continued Sunderland’s successful youth-oriented policy from cost-effective markets, with the likes of Noah Sadiki, and record signing Habib Diarra arriving from Belgian and French sides. It also confronted a lack of experience, which is crucial in the Premier League, particularly in defence. Take for example, the arrivals of seasoned La Liga stars Reinildo and Omar Alderete, and the marquee signing of ex-Arsenal captain Granit Xhaka.   

The Black Cats have been eye-catching, and there is cause for optimism given internal ambition, and the precarity surrounding more established clubs, specifically, Brentford, Wolves, and West Ham.  

Brentford have lost key personnel and continuity through Yoanne Wissa, Christian Norgaard, and Thomas Frank’s departures. West Ham are in disarray with Graham Potter at the helm, the inconsistent chairmanship of David Sullivan, and the loss of stalwarts including Mohammed Kudus. Wolves’ fans have dismayed over the direction of the club under Fosun International, particularly the annual downscaling of the squad, with Matheus Cunha and Rayan Ait-Nouri departing.  

The task remains arduous, yet a newly promoted club, Sunderland or not, can absolutely cement their Premier League credentials. The division’s lower mid-table sides are under pressure.  

.