Israeli boycott issue goes to referendum
AS A RESULT of the recent DSU debate which took place on the 22nd January, the DSU will now be holding a full-scale university referendum lasting five days, Palatinate can reveal.
The council meeting was initially held to debate an economic boycott of Israeli goods. The motion, put forward by the DSU’s Environment and Ethics officer Jonathan Collinson, planned to boycott products in the DSU shop which have been produced in Israel and not allow any Israeli state owned companies into Dunelm House.
Jonathan Collinson, despite facing criticism, was keen to reiterate that the debate was merely to vote for a boycott tactic rather than discussing the current political situation in Gaza. He stated “We want to act because we have teeth. Together we have bite but somebody has to start it off – no matter how small that impact may be.”
One student argued, “The boycott is not merely about economic and financial reasons but a more moralistic issue,” prompting one student to ask whether the motion “had any real consideration for a practical effect?”
Indeed, when questioned over the actual impact this would have on the economy, not only of the Israeli government, but of the DSU, DSU President Andy Welch was unable to comment.
“We don’t know what we stock”, Welch said. “At the moment it is too costly to work it out so we were going to wait for a result of the debate and then work it out.”
The lengthy debate, comprising of both DSU council and exec members, as well as Durham University students, remained inconclusive because it was decided that as the Queen’s campus students had to catch the last bus home, those students’ views would not be represented.
Student Matt Kane then argued for a referendum mid-way through the discussion instead, suggesting “These are just circular arguments and some of us want to go to the pub!
’There are only 60 voting students in this room how can we represent 15,000 people?”
Needing a two third majority vote to be passed, the referendum was rejected during the council meeting.
Seva Philips, the senior DSU rep for Van Mildert college commented, “A referendum undermines the power of the council to come to come to a solution about things.”
Yet finally, in a last minute twist and the Council having already voted out a referendum, one student proposed a petition to take the motion to referendum.
Under normal circumstances the motion would be discussed further by the DSU.
However, because this petition has now reached the 3% target of DSU membership, the referendum will go ahead regardless. This means that now all Durham University students can vote on the issue.
Durham University Vice Chancellor, Professor Chris Higgins, has supported the debate, “That’s what student life is about: debate. As long as it’s in a thoughtful and constructive and respectful fashion. The only danger is that a small minority can push through extreme views.”
The DSU chair of the debate resolved, “This issue isn’t going to go away. We need to discuss it in the most democratic and sensible way possible.”
DSU President Andy Welch said of the debate, “I have been very pleased with the turnout.”
The referendum will be held early next week.
– – –
521 Signatorees signed the petition
43 Council votes in favour of referendum
6 Abstentions
