Is ‘woke culture’ the death of comedy?
By Charles Kershaw
The year is 2019. It is a bright cold day in October, and the clocks are striking thirteen. All free speech has been banned. Comedy is no longer possible, because if it offends a single person in society the comedian will immediately be “cancelled”. In this woke culture, the only media that survives is pre-approved by Twitter, so sanitised and inoffensive that it has absolutely nothing to say.
Except that is not the society we live in, contrary to what some might lead you to believe. On the contrary; comedy is alive, well, and – dare I say it – thriving.
Comedy is alive, well, and thriving.
So why does Todd Phillips, director of the new Joker movie, believe that it’s no longer possible to be funny? There has been much debate recently over the concept of “cancel culture” – the idea that, in this day and age, angry mobs on the internet can “cancel” people – as if they were a television series – if they do or say things that they perceive as even slightly offensive. This is simply not the case, and “cancel culture” as a concept doesn’t actually exist.
I won’t deny that over the past few years people have become more sensitive when it comes to topics concerning race, gender identity and sexuality. We have seen some important benefits due to this. Granted, we still have a long way to go, but we have made great strides. And because of this, we have become more aware of how jokes can harm – for example, by reducing a group to a single, inaccurate stereotype.
As a result of this increase in “wokeness”, comedians have been affected; Kevin Hart was meant to host the Oscars this year, yet stepped down after tweets and a stand up routine emerged of him being homophobic; similarly James Gunn was fired from directing Guardians of the Galaxy, Vol. 3. Yet before you point to these people as victims of “cancel culture”, may I point out to you that every one of their careers is continuing to flourish?
Kevin Hart is about to star in Jumanji: The Next Level, a sequel to a blockbuster that he was also in, James Gunn is set to direct a new Suicide Squad with a star-studded cast, The only comedians’ careers that have truly suffered are Louis CK and Bill Cosby- both of whom were “cancelled” due to allegations of sexual assault and harassment, not due to the jokes they made on stage.
And what of Dave Chapelle, whose stand-up routines regularly mention the sensitivity of the current climate? Despite his laments at the danger of upsetting the “alphabet people” (his term for the LGBTQ+ community), his most recent Netflix special was heavily promoted and made him 20 million dollars richer. Critics haven’t rated it quite so highly as previous specials, but it’s not, as many claim, because they’re overly offended “snowflakes”, but rather because the material is lacking compared to his previous work.
Where previously Chapelle had given us an insight into life as a black man in America in a manner which was both poignant and hilarious, now he resorts to “punching down” with his comedy. His jokes aimed at the transgender community have absolutely no depth to them, relying solely on the tired “what if people identified as x” joke. It’s easy for him and his fans to hide behind the “you’re all too offended” excuse, but perhaps he and others like him should learn that it requires more than offensiveness to be actually funny.
So, if you want to watch something which “couldn’t be made today” that was, watch South Park, watch the new movie where Taika Waititi plays an imaginary Hitler, or any of the comedians I’ve mentioned – they’re all still around. If you’re a comedian, don’t expect to get any sympathy if people don’t find your casual racism and bigotry as funny as you do.
Image by Madeleine Rosie Strom
