Is the future of literature genderless?
By Ingrid Schreiber

He, she, it, they. What possible information or insight can such tiny words afford a story? I remember the moment a few years ago when I realised all of my favourite novels were narrated by women, and I began to wonder what that said about me and my ability to relate to others. Was I drawn to these characters because of some deep, underlying kinship or merely by sheer statistical probability, having encountered them through the kindly recommendations of librarians and the gifts of well-meaning family members?
Gender is a complex topic and it’s easy to get lost among the dense and often waffly poststructuralist understandings of the gendered self. In literature, the problem extends far beyond which stories you find yourself particularly invested in: you only need take one glance inside a Waterstones or a WH Smith to recognise the concept of gender is central to the politics of the publishing industry. The producer, the medium, the audience: everything is gendered in the consumption of story-telling. Pink covers here, geometric fonts there. Female writers publishing their fantasy or science-fiction works under pseudonyms or initials. Sometimes it seems like a self-fulfilling prophecy that little boys don’t want to read about little girls and vice versa.
Marketing theory tells us that gender sells: consumers are drawn to purchases which make them feel reassured of a concrete self-identity. Yet, in a world where gender is becoming an increasingly obsolete facet of individual character, we have an obligation to wonder exactly what it is we are selling with these specifically gendered genres and character traits. In some ways, the divide grows smaller and smaller with every new feisty heroine embarking on her hero’s journey in some dystopian universe. In the majority of cases, however, books which achieve mainstream success still feature traditionally gendered characters: ambitious and resourceful men, and emotional and dependent women.
Stephanie Meyer’s recent gender swapping experiment, Life and Death: Twilight Reimagined, did little to challenge the gap between normative feminine and masculine roles; in fact, the media response was overwhelmingly negative and claimed that the relationship between “Beau” and “Edythe” no longer made any cultural sense for readers. Young adult fiction may represent the extreme end of gendered story-telling, but even within adult fiction, protagonists are often specifically and not incidentally gendered; that is, their identity depends largely on the genre they narrate. Furthermore, transgender and intersex perspectives remain dangerously underrepresented.

Overall, it seems a misguidedly optimistic approach to expect gender to just fizzle off of our shelves in the coming years. The gender binary remains a convenient and profitable way to organise the market. Theoretically, a world of genderless protagonists would be a stark political statement for the equality of all human beings, the literary equivalent of the recent Swedish adoption of a gender-neutral pronoun. In reality, however, it would be a denial of the essential subjectivity of literature. Thanks to the fundamentally social nature of the human maturation process, nobody escapes the gender binary. What ultimate benefit could there then be in writing or reading a genderless or gender-swapped perspective? Talking of John Eyres and Olivia Twists seems to forget that the beauty of literature lies in its ability to capture the diversity of human experiences and the contingent circumstances which shape them. So long as the gender binary remains meaningful for real lives, it cannot be erased from the page. Perhaps the best we can hope for is a more inclusive publishing industry and a new generation of writers who embrace the multiplicity of modern gender instead of reproducing the myth of mutually exclusive male and female perspectives.
