Is the artist exempt?
By Tom Watling
The cliché of the university politicising the student is an old one. What is new, though, is the political situation outside of universities, and the impact it has had on us. Political correctness, reformative campaigns and no platforming are shaping the western world, especially on university campuses, to the point where we are encouraged to challenge and assuage even our own daily language. Now, I do not oppose this; in fact, I think it’s a big step forwards, but it sometimes tramples into troubled waters. It has opened up a few big questions, one of which I would like to broach today.
My particular interest lies in the issue of no platforming. As university students, we are part of a group of people largely responsible for the utilisation of no platforming. University students pioneered it; they’ve practiced it and they continue to implement it. A plethora of different speakers, many of which possess different political proclivities, have been banned from speaking at universities across the country and the world. People spend hours traipsing through the arguments for and against a certain speaker being given a platform, but only recently have music and musicians been pulled into the boiling pot.
People spend hours traipsing through the arguments for and against a certain speaker being given a platform, but only recently have music and musicians been pulled into the boiling pot.
Several months ago, Spotify introduced a Hate Content & Hateful Conduct policy, which aimed to promote “openness, diversity, tolerance and respect.” The policy noted that “When an artist or creator does something that is especially harmful or hateful (for example, violence against children and sexual violence), it may affect the ways we work with or support that artist or creator.” This is part on part the premise of no platforming.
As a result of this policy, R. Kelly and the late XXXTENTACION were removed from Spotify’s home-made playlists. The former had been accused of sexual grooming a fourteen-year-old, the latter had been outed for abuse.
However, this policy did not last long. Artists such as Kendrick Lamar were quick to oppose it, threatening to remove their own music if the policy continued to be practiced. The reasons behind his insurrection were multitudinous, but were rooted in the idea that the media is not legitimised in controlling who is and who is not supported. Ultimately, the ridiculous number of artists culpable of misconduct captured by the policy, and the even more ridiculous proposition of removing them all, would syllogise a discriminatory rigmarole detrimental to an artist’s freedom and growth. Essentially, it was felt to be a suffocating tactic opposing the bedrock of art and music alike: the idea of expression without parameters.
Now, I am not suggesting that artists, whether it be musicians, actors or writers, should be exempt from the moral codes that the everyday layman is held up to; that would be abstruse. Nor am I implying that musicians should be able to talk about whatever they want. Whilst I don’t necessarily agree with the moral panic engendered by the media over drill music, for example, I recognise that this is something that needs addressing. But when it comes to holding artists to a moral standard, it is far more complex than the process of no platforming a political lecturer, for artists, and musicians particularly, are celebrated for their art; that which is usually distinct from their beliefs. Of course, Tupac Shakur’s politics and music went hand in hand, and he is a prime example of the many artists whose politics are inseparable from their lyrics, but it is not the words I’m necessarily talking about.
When it comes to holding artists to a moral standard, it is far more complex than the process of no platforming a political lecturer.
Music is fundamentally a noise that appeals to the ear. There is a wealth of corollaries, but ultimately, someone listens to a certain type of music because they like the sound. You can listen to a song and ignore the lyrics; you cannot listen to a song and ignore the melody. In the same way that, though I rebuke his licentiousness, I love Woody Allen’s film ‘Annie Hall,’ or, though I oppose his penchant for spiking unaware people with LSD, I read and re-read Ken Kesey’s book ‘One Flew Over the Cuckoo Nest,’ I feel comfortable listening to the music I love despite knowledge of their misbehaviour, more or less because I love the sound.

So, I find myself mercilessly opposing the notion that the influential should get away with murder simply because of their status whilst also mercilessly opposing the idea that the influential should not be heard. This is what separates the political speakers from the artists: one’s character is inextricably linked to their content; the other is only partially so.
It’s high time people started paying this issue more attention, lest it creeps up on us before anyone has had enough time to formulate an opinion. The liberalisation of language and society, in so far as it becomes more inclusive, is something that deserves to be encouraged, but equally, it creates an awful number of issues that require solving. No platforming in the music business is one of these issues, and it is slowly poking its head over the parapet. Spotify, like all the streaming services, does not require public permission to halt its support of certain artists, and this has a dangerous effect on the industry as a whole. It cannot be ignored.
Images by Sorosh Tavakoli & Reckon via Flickr Creative Commons
