Is the Andrew scandal the last straw for the monarchy?
By Daisie Mackay
The monarchy has been around since the inception of our nation; many think that it unequivocally represents Britishness, charity, and public service. I, however, do not. When we look further into the monarchy, we see a shrouded history; there is secrecy, a lack of accountability, not to mention a stark and destructive imperialist streak. However this mystery is coming to the fore. The public have had enough of it, with recent Ipsos polling showing that 37% of Britons believe abolishing the monarchy would be worse for the country, down from 47% just three months ago. And this has been reflected in Parliament’s recent rhetoric, for the first-time openly criticising a member of the royal family, Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor. Even the government could not withhold its revulsion, with Trade Minister Chris Bryant calling the former prince a “rude, arrogant and entitled man who could not distinguish between the public interest, which he said he served, and his own private interest”. From being caught up in the Epstein files with accusations of sexual abuse towards women and girls (which he has, of course, always denied), as well as now having reportedly spread state secrets, Andrew is yet another stain on the royal family’s long, loaded, and often lawless legacy.
While the King did remove Andrew’s titles and kick him out of Royal Lodge (to a more modest five-bedroom home on Sandringham Estate), and while this is the biggest shake-up of the royal family in a long while, it simply does not go far enough. Questions have been raised yet again, and this time far more loudly, about the beloved-by-many late Queen’s role in bankrolling Andrew’s absolution of his sins, including when he settled a 2022 court case for £12 million with his most prominent accuser, Virginia Giuffre. And from this, how much did the British taxpayer pay towards it? The monarchy as an institution needs to lose this layer of protection, its veil of mystery. Most people have no idea how much money goes towards them or what it is spent on: they are completely unaccountable.
It is an insult to the many who have suffered from British imperialism to uphold the monarchy as a source of pride and culture
Furthermore, Andrew had an explicitly political role as a trade envoy from 2001 to 2011, and he should, like any other person in such a role, be scrutinised. Yet for so long he has not been under this same level of pressure because of this antiquated convention that the royal family shall not be discussed in Parliament. But now Parliament have finally, at least somewhat, grown a backbone (hallelujah!); they have shaken their entrenched deference to the royals, with the aforementioned debate being a striking example of this.
Unprecedented steps are being taken by the government to get involved in the royal family’s affairs: they are calling for Andrew to be removed from his place as eighth in line to the throne, with Defence Minister Luke Pollard describing this as “the right thing to do”. Now, while these developments do bode well for democracy, in seeking accountability from a previously untouchable institution, there is still more to be said about the place of the monarchy in our society. There are 43 countries in the world with monarchies, fifteen of which have Charles as their king. Fifteen countries. This is clearly a colonial legacy; the strength and reach of the monarchy is a symbol of Britain’s exploitative past. From slavery to the stealing of cultural artefacts, the fact that its reach still extends to many of these countries that have suffered at the hands of Britain should be a stamp of shame on this country. Yet still, many justify the monarchy’s existence because “it’s just nice” or “it’s part of our culture!”. One cannot morally justify this claim when faced with the harsh reality of the history upon which the monarchy was built. The imperial past of Britain will continue to haunt the country so long as the monarchy exists, and it is an insult to the many who have suffered from British imperialism to uphold the monarchy as a source of pride and culture.
Moving past this romantic argument for the monarchy’s existence, there are still many who seek to rationally justify it on the basis of tourism and thereby the revenue it generates. To that I say: the Palace of Versailles is one of the most visited sites in France. They got rid of their monarchy over 200 years ago, and the country is still able to economically thrive from it. Now, I am by no means calling for us to behead Charles, but we must critically reflect on how necessary this institution is. It is a relic of an imperialist past; an unaccountable, expensive, and mysterious organisation, and it is time to realise that we can no longer justify accepting this. It is time to fully step into the modern era. It is time to get rid of the monarchy.
Image: Ilee_wu via Flickr

