Is Russia re-writing history?
By Matthew Kent
On the 9th May, Russia will celebrate a special Victory Day; 75 years since the Nazis surrendered to the Red Army in Berlin.
Russia has already succeeded in making the label ‘fascist’ applicable to any international enemy
Red square will boast an even bigger military parade than usual, complete with millions proudly adorning a black-and-orange ribbon and Soviet iconography galore. The Russian propaganda machine will be ready to mould and exploit every bit of it. It has already succeeded in making the label ‘fascist’ applicable to any international enemy, thereby comparing the US to Nazi Germany casually and regularly; it is gradually undoing years of de-Stalinisation with statues and systematic apologetics; and it panders to the administration by airing and perpetuating Putin’s counter-narrative that Poland was to blame for the start of what Russians call the ‘Great Patriotic War’.
We have learned to expect such behaviour from Russian media, politics and society. But before we jump behind the outrage from its Western counterparts, we should consider that no-one’s hands are clean. As the number of veterans dwindles, every side has the morbid opportunity to let the first-hand experience take a back seat and push its own historical narrative. For a start, Russia’s significance is mercilessly underplayed in Western discourse on the war. The Soviet Union lost at least 24 million citizens in the war – if China is excluded from estimates, that is more than every other country combined. That truth ought not to be shocking, yet the emphasis placed on British and American efforts are so significant that the Soviets are excluded from common knowledge of the war.
Indeed, Putin’s latest attacks on Poland’s historical contribution were only in response to a revisionist and needlessly inflammatory motion passed by the European Parliament, where Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union were blamed equally for the Second World War. Whilst some of the motion was spot-on – the internal regimes of Hitler and Stalin were equally awful, and Russia’s reframing of a non-aggression pact with the Nazis in 1939 has been questionable at best – Europe is providing propaganda fodder for Russia and stooping to their level by brandishing gross simplifications for questions that are best left to professional historians.
Russia’s significance is mercilessly underplayed in Western discourse on the war
Meanwhile, Polish politicians downplay their nation’s role in facilitating Nazi concentration camps on their territory. Romania, Ukraine and the Baltics consistently swipe under the carpet evidence of widespread collaboration and complicity in Nazi crimes. At home, we saw numerous politicians offering comparisons of Britain winning the war with leaving the European Union. This may have been rightly dismissed by many as absurd – but even having it uttered by important figures and circulated widely online shows just how easily the memories of the war can be politicised.
So, when you see Russia’s glorification of victory on 9th May, don’t just dismiss it as a typical authoritarian manoeuvre, or as proof that Russia is an aggressor. Look back home and see how Britain and her allies can do better than use the memories of millions to make contemporary political points.
Image: Ak Pk via Flickr
