Is rock authentic enough?
By Emi Sharples
Last September, I went to see one of my favourite live gigs to date — a show that will no doubt exist vividly in my mind for a long time to come. One of my favourite bands of all time, Basement, played at Electric Bristol supported by Midrift, Dynamite, and Anxious. In a city I had never been to before, seeing supporting bands I had never even heard of — but fulfilling a long-term dream in the process — I somehow left the show with a new-found sense of community, self, and purpose.
Reading ‘The Savage Empathy of the Mosh Pit’, an article written for The Atlantic by James Parker, brought back this feeling months later in swathes. Parker ascertains “What if the pit […] could teach us something about how to live together in 2025 — about how to be?” — what if there really is a point to all of this? I’m not sure I’ve ever read anything that so coherently understands the kinds of seemingly paradoxical emotions and revelations felt in a show’s pit. One overarching word comes to mind: catharsis. It’s this undeniable desire for human connection that runs in the undercurrent of rock music that’s reflected in its musical craft; the distorted and often imperfectly textured guitars, the drums which respond differently with each hit, and vocal delivery which bears all. There’s something so beautiful in how remarkably human it all is.
There’s something so beautiful in how remarkably human it all is
This authenticity is only elevated through live performances. House rock shows, to me, are undeniably paramount. The smaller the space, the more real everything feels — not just in the “here and now” sense, but in a way which makes life feel like it’s somehow more worth living. People have a funny way of deriving meaning from art. Some may closely attach their personal experiences to it, some focus on lyrical meaning, some on emotions evoked by the sounds themselves, and some delve into interviews and ruminations on how the music came to be constructed. The ability to see both authorial intent and audience interpretation not just in person, but in such close and intimate proximity gives the music another dimension would have otherwise gone untapped.
But, arguably, art doesn’t necessitate truth. The underlying assertion that rock has to be ‘authentic’ feels to be a responsive pushback to technological dominance in the 21st Century. Not just its dominance, but the way technology has evolved to serve us and, ironically, limit us — ‘doing for’ instead of ‘helping with’. It’s the AI artists with millions of Spotify listeners not just encroaching on the act of creativity we consider distinctly human but undermining the ability of artists to even survive. From one subgenre to the next, rock has always been about finding community with those that don’t necessarily comply to the mainstream. This feeling underpins a cultural countermovement: in the face of phenomenally high levels of pop perfection, aesthetics of natural beauty becoming the norm (see TikTok’s “clean girl” and all its variants), and digital alterations made to ‘perfect’ of all types of media, people are beginning to reject attempts to be polished as the standards become more and more unreasonable. More than this, an increasingly digitalised perfectionism seems an inherent juxtaposition to the reality that rock seeks to uphold.
Where do we draw the line between sincerity and falsehood when technology is increasingly used in place of the human touch — especially in music which seeks to connect us?
Where do we draw the line between sincerity and falsehood when technology is increasingly used in place of the human touch — especially in music which seeks to connect us?
This year’s Grammy awards serve as a good case study to examine the modern rock landscape; with quite a few nominations across the Grammys feeling somewhat hollow, and critical reception being the favoured rubric, the Grammy nominations are nonetheless a good litmus test to see what the internet deems worthy enough to live up to the superlative nature of the categories. Alongside heavyweights Deftones and Linkin Park nominated in the Best Rock Album category, Turnstile came home victorious with an evolved sound that has come to define their turning point in 2026. Turnstile’s winning album NEVER ENOUGH employs not just certain digital flourishes, but a distinctly digital character through sterile and clear-cut guitar tones, which whilst possess the labels of being ‘strong’ and ‘distorted’, ironically make each track’s instrumentation feel weak and like an overcompensation. This is not particularly helped by the album’s songwriting either, which often relies upon incredibly repetitive riffs and song structures, generally thin layering of instrumentation, and a clean reverb which makes its artistry feel a little clinical. Even the brass ornaments on the song ‘DREAMING’ feel artificial despite being recorded in-studio. This characterises the album far past just being the Grammy-winning rock album of 2026 — rather, a strong indicator of where rock is headed in the modern age.
To an extent, I get it. Music evolves with time, adapting to our cultural shifts and the technologies which facilitate this – and all things considered, some of the songs on the album are accomplished. ‘LIGHT DESIGN’, ‘SEEIN’ STARS’, ‘NEVER ENOUGH’, ‘I CARE’ and ‘BIRDS’ are firm standouts, with the latter being nominated for the Grammys’ Best Metal Performance and going viral as part of the band’s NPR Tiny Desk Concert set. NEVER ENOUGH also clearly seeks to be an atmospheric album, having clear transitions between certain songs and lengthier instrumentals, such as ‘SUNSHOWER’s elongated flute outro or the mellowed ending of ‘LOOK OUT FOR ME’, which seek to execute some sonic worldbuilding.
The dissonance feels a little too much to ignore
To my mind, NEVER ENOUGH as an album is perfectly fine. But as 2026’s Best Rock Album, it’s something slightly different. It tells of what is rewarded as profitable, what is commendable, and what seems to be universally desired from rock in the next few years — and I just think of the house gigs; the grassroots venues; that singular, unifying feeling I felt at that Basement gig in September. The dissonance feels a little too much to ignore.
Image: Emi Sharples

