Is poetry dead?

By Sarah Fletcher

 

For some reason or another, poetry is announced dead every few years or so. And yet, like Rasputin or termites, poetry continues to survive despite these pronouncements. The T.S. Eliot Prize (the biggest award for contemporary poetry collections) continues to draw crowds of 2,000 plus each year. The Foyle Young Poet of the Year Award — an award for poets under the age of seventeen — continues to attract more and more submissions from aspiring young writers. Performers like Kate Tempest and Scroobius Pip blend spoken word poetry with rap and are met with incredible popularity. Every few months or so, a poem goes viral on the internet and will fill my Facebook newsfeed: The Rape Joke by Patricia Lockwood, If I Should Have A Daughter by Sarah Kay, or Home by Warsan Shire.

No other art form — painting, jazz, opera — is plagued with these constant assessments of death while continuing to thrive. And while most university students could name the poet laureate — Carol Ann Duffy — or other popular poets like Simon Armitage and John Agard, many would struggle to bring to mind active contemporary artists or classic musicians. So why the double standard?

I’d wager that this stems from the idea that poetry, being a written form, should be as popular as prose and, in failing to meet this standard, is somehow doing something wrong. But to compare the two is to compare apples and oranges; it’s like expecting classical music or opera to be as popular as pop. It’s like comparing household pottery to sculpture. Poetry and prose offer two entirely different reading experiences, so to expect people to read poetry before bed the way they’d read a novel is a false perception. Poetry requires time and patience — its success is contingent on a reader not reading it like prose with line breaks. Poetry doesn’t depend on cliff-hangers and suspenseful plots the way novels do, and prose can tolerate sleepy, skimmed reading much more than a poem. When we stop comparing poetry’s popularity to prose, we will realise that poetry is not only alive and well, but bursting at the seams with new life and creative innovation.

I myself have always considered other forms, like music, or architecture, or comedy as closer to poetry than even prose — especially comedy. Both are forms that are conscious of timing: the comedian with his or her presentation, and the poet with his or her line and stanza breaks. People laugh at comedy because they recognise something relatable and true they’ve never realised before; this experience being quite similar to Harold Bloom’s theory of the ‘uncanny’: that successful poetic texts are successful because they tap into feelings of something both recognisable and out of reach.

Last week, I re-watched a Noel Fielding performance where he describes turning forty as turning into a “day old helium balloon; you’re not on the sky and not on the floor”. Everybody laughed, and I couldn’t help but imagine the same phrase with line breaks, perhaps in a poem with a generic title like “Ageing”:

 

“Turning forty

is becoming

a day old helium balloon;

 

not on the sky

and not on the floor.”

 

The phrase immediately becomes sad and reflective rather than funny. To me, it showed that the public is still receptive to poetic phrasing and poetic imagery. Poetry is not under-read because we live in a disinterested, cold society with no capacity to feel. I don’t believe it’s under-read because the public views it as too difficult (the GSCE poetry program in the UK certainly showing that not all poetry need be as difficult as Eliot or Pound). We just need to take the time to appreciate poetry and give poems the time they deserves. And we often do! People go to poetry for solace during times of grief; people read poems for celebration at weddings and birthdays — it’s considered the ‘sunday best’ of language. But as long as we continue to expect poetry – which is becoming newer and more varied every day — to unfairly compete with prose, false eulogies for the form will continue to breed. It’s time to put those admonitions to rest, rather than poetry itself.

Photograph: Metropolitan Transportation Authority via Flickr