Is Netanyahu the biggest obstacle to peace in Gaza?
By James Gordon
Israel has been rocked by a wave of protests in recent weeks, in response to the gut-wrenching discovery of the bodies of six Israeli hostages brutally killed by Hamas. The shock of their deaths, coupled with a harrowing video released by the military depicting the inhumane conditions the hostages endured, has sparked mass demonstrations across the country. Protestors are fervently urging the government to swiftly negotiate a deal for the safe return of the remaining hostages. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has found himself at the centre of the protestors’ fury, with some suggesting that he is prolonging the war to appease the far-right members of his coalition. These members have repeatedly threatened to bring down his government if he signs any peace treaty with Hamas.Â
Frustration [in Washington] is mounting over what is perceived as Benjamin Netanyahu’s reluctance to end the war
The protests may have been quietly welcomed in Washington, where frustration is mounting over what is perceived as Benjamin Netanyahu’s reluctance to end the war. When asked if the Israeli Prime Minister was doing enough to end the war in Gaza, US President Joe Biden simply answered, “No.” While the US has not commented officially, it has been made publicly known that Israel’s latest demand is to maintain control of two strips of land in Gaza, known as the Netzarim and Philadelpi Corridor. The protests, however, could potentially shift the dynamics and bring about the desired change.Â
As one might expect, Hamas and Egypt strongly oppose the suggested occupation, especially as the Philadelphi corridor lies along Gaza’s border with Egypt, giving Israel lasting control over the Rafah border crossing. Israel claims it needs to maintain a presence in this territory due to a cross-border tunnel network used by Hamas to smuggle weapons. Yet, in response to this Israeli fear, Egypt asserts to have destroyed such infrastructure and retorts that Israel does not need a buffer zone at Rafah since it already has one in eastern Sinai, bordering Gaza. Therefore, Egypt’s argument is that Israel does not need a buffer zone on both sides of the border. It is unclear whether the demanded occupation of Netzarim and Philadelpi is a new demand by Israel or a continuation of a previous proposal.Â
With Washington’s patience already wearing thin after an American protestor was killed by soldiers of the Israeli Defence Force, fresh Israeli demands are likely to further frustrate mediator countries who have been trying to reach a ceasefire agreement for months. Despite the increasing domestic and international pressure, Mr Netanyahu seems unwilling to change course. After the latest murder of Israeli hostages by Hamas, the PM once again vowed to continue fighting until the organisation is destroyed and all hostages freed. To many Israelis, the hawkish pro-war attitude flaunted by the government seems to have moved beyond merely rescuing the hostages with prospects for peace to be of secondary importance.Â
This new war-weary public perception could potentially influence the government’s decision-making process and the future direction of the conflict
Cynically, Hamas appears to have come to the same realisation as the Israeli protestors. Recent hostage executions implies that Hamas no longer considers their civilian captives as bargaining chips for gaining valuable concessions. In fact, one might say it has been to Hamas’ advantage that the anger at the protests in Israel seems to have been primarily directed at the Netanyahu government rather than Hamas itself. This possible shift in public opinion is perhaps the most significant change in Israeli political dynamics in recent weeks. Such a change suggests that large parts of the Israeli public have moved past the sense of national unity that came from the trauma of the October 7th attacks almost a year ago and are now taking a more pragmatic view on a speedy end to the war. This new war-weary public perception could potentially influence the government’s decision-making process and the future direction of the conflict. Whether Mr. Netanyahu takes heed of this change in public sentiment is another matter entirely, but it could have significant implications for the future of the war in Gaza.
Image: Prime Minister of Israel via Flickr

