Is journalism facing an existential threat?

By Flo Clifford

Danny Fenster, a US journalist working for an independent outlet in Myanmar, was recently sentenced to 11 years in prison by the country’s military junta. Since the junta seized power in a coup in February it has cracked down on the press, restricting reporting, cutting off internet access, and banning certain news outlets critical of its repressive military rule. Myanmar has been rocked by waves of almost-daily protests since the seizure of power and over a thousand civilians have been killed. 

Fenster, as managing editor of the Frontier Myanmar paper, oversaw much-needed coverage of events unfolding. 

The arrest of Fenster marks a worrying development and condemns him to potentially never again seeing beyond the walls of a prison in a dictatorial regime

Fenster’s lawyers and family argue he has been imprisoned and sentenced for doing his job. For the junta, however, he is guilty of incitement under a new law banning what it deems ‘fake news’, contacting illegal organisations, and violating visa laws. He now faces further charges of under sedition and anti-terrorism laws, which will likely result — each — in a life sentence. 

Myanmar’s crackdown on the press had, until now, spared foreign journalists working independently. Thus, the arrest of Fenster, at an airport in May, marks a worrying development and condemns him to potentially never again seeing beyond the walls of a prison in a dictatorial regime. 

It is not just Myanmar; in recent years we have witnessed an alarming rise in crimes against journalists worldwide. From repression and unlawful arrests to brutal murders like that of the Maltese reporter Daphne Caruana Galizia who in 2017 was blown up in her own car. To say journalism is vulnerable in unstable political climates is to grossly understate the issue: in reality, serious journalism is at risk of dying out globally.

Journalists reporting in places such as China, Myanmar, and Russia face the constant risk of intimidation, threats, imprisonment, lawsuits, and often death. In recent months several journalists in China who were investigating the government’s handling of the pandemic have gone missing or been arrested and held in horrific conditions. Powerful governments are entwined with grisly murder allegations. The Saudi government was implicated in the assassination of Jamal Khashoggi — something which the UK and the rest of the world seem to have cast aside. Journalists will fight a losing battle in a world rigged against them unless action is taken to end the impunity with which they are tried, convicted, and killed.

To say journalism is vulnerable in unstable political climates is to grossly understate the issue: in reality serious journalism is at risk of dying out globally

Over the past decade, a journalist has been killed, on average, every four days. In recent years this has been seen not just on frontlines or in war-torn countries, but also as retaliation for covering corruption, political and environmental crimes, human rights violations, and general wrongdoing. 

Thus, to focus only on countries grappling with internal conflict and repressive regimes like Myanmar is to ignore the bigger picture: it is journalism everywhere that faces a truly existential threat. We are no stranger to this in the UK. Recently proposed reforms to the Official Secrets Act would see press freedom stifled, with journalists and whistleblowers who leak information facing up to 14 years in prison.

Over the past year journalists in the UK have exposed the mishandling of the pandemic, multimillion-pound contracts going to ministerial contacts, and widespread government corruption, yet the government is looking to erode the media freedoms that hold it accountable. Government departments, accused of frequent stonewalling Freedom of Information Act requests, are also looking to weaken laws around it to avoid further embarrassment from a scandal which has plagued them in recent months. Even in a relatively democratic country, journalism still is fraught with existential threats. 

A November 2020 UNESCO report on the Safety of Journalists and the Danger of Impunity said that over that year, only 13% of global cases of crimes against journalists were considered resolved — 87% faced no consequence. As time goes on more strident calls are being made to end impunity for crimes against journalists and to restore security for people doing an essential and dangerous task. 

In the world we live in now, of misinformation, judicial breakdown, and rampant political corruption and cover-ups, this is more significant than it has ever been. If nothing changes, and journalism remains under ever-increasing threat, freedom of expression for all and democracy itself will be the victims. 

Image: AbsolutVision via Unsplash.