Is It’s A Wonderful Life the best Christmas film ever?

by Alex Leadbeater
There are plenty of film’s that use Christmas as a setting, but are hard to define as a Christmas film. Lethal Weapon may have its final showdown set against a backdrop of brightly decorated suburbia, but tonally it is the furthest you can get from the festive spirit. No, it is less the surroundings (such as Wednesday’s choice Die Hard) and more the feeling of the film. Just as the best Christmas song (Fairytale Of New York, obviously) isn’t directly about Christmas, more encapsulating the social emotion, the best Christmas films are often those that aim to capture that sense of love and unconditional compassion. The most retold festive story in film, A Christmas Carol is a definite example of this; it’s a Christmas Eve set tale that concerns itself more with human spirit rather than the holiday – Scrooge becomes a good man for the whole year, not just 25th December.
This is an element that is equally true of the greatest Christmas movie of all time; Frank Capra’s masterful It’s A Wonderful Life. Following mediocre reviews upon release in 1946, it has over time been re-evaluated as a classic (thanks to a mixture of cultural hindsight and fortunate failures in copyrighting). Named the most inspirational film of the past hundred years by the American Film Institute, it is now a staple Christmas showing at cinemas across the world.
Yet for the majority of its run time, the film is a very un-festive affair. Following desperate prayers from the population Bedford Falls, trainee angel Clarence is given the task to save one man – George Bailey – who we see grow from a popular and heroic child with big dreams to successful but ultimately downtrodden man. But despite the cheer we get in seeing George excitedly planning to lasso the moon and keeping his family business from the clutches of greed, it’s all underpinned with the heartbreak of his inability to leave; his plans of travelling, college and even a honeymoon are consistently put on hold due to his sense of duty. It is only after an hour and a half we get to Christmas and even then it used as juxtaposition for a man’s slowly degrading mental state.
Played with the perfect balance of gleefulness and pathos by screen legend James Stewart, we really root for George, feeling the real tragedy of seeing his younger brother go out into the world and make a name for himself, while he remains stuck in Bedford Falls. It all feels incredibly natural, with a mixture of good fortune, personal mistakes and sheer bad luck all affecting George and those around him. The first part of the film poses the tragic thought of longing to escape but ever unable to leave. All this depression would be for naught, however, if it wasn’t for the eventual payoff.

Driven to the brink by one problem after another, George is ready to commit suicide (and how many Christmas classics have the balls to do that?) until Clarence intervenes and grants him his wish of seeing a terrifying alternate reality in which he was never born where we such just how big a positive affect George has had. And that is ultimately what the film is about, that drive to be good and do good things, compounded by the emotive but never saccharine ending that hammers home just how important a man George Bailey is.
But no matter the brilliance of the film, it is its endurance that makes it the one true great. The image of George Bailey, family grouped around him is an iconic embodiment of Christmas and there can’t be anyone who doesn’t know the so-happy-you’ll-cry ending. And the wholesome message is a relevant and true now as it was sixty-six years ago. As one of the townspeople says at the film’s climax, George Bailey is the richest man in town. But he isn’t referring to the cash his friends have lovingly dolled out; he’s talking about the love that he gives and receives, a never more relevant Christmas message.
It is a true Christmas classic that can appeal to all ages – unlike many classics from childhood we all hold dear, it stands up against a sense of nostalgia and reaches beyond generational gaps. It’s a Wonderful Life is a mainstay of my Christmas Eve’s and will be for many years to come.
