Is Goodreads really all good?

By Cara Burdon

This year my mindset towards recreational reading has changed, I would like to think, for the better. As nice as it is to exchange Goodreads usernames with friends to get inspiration from other people’s book tastes and as helpful as it is to have a reminder of the books you’ve read at your fingertips, I’ve come to realise that sometimes the cons of tracking everything you read often outweigh the pros. 

Before this aforementioned change of mindset, I used to religiously track everything I read and used to put so much pressure on myself to check books off my ‘to be read’ list within a certain timeframe. As silly as this sounds, I developed a genuine fear that if I neglected my rigid reading schedule I would lose braincells, which, needless to say, is completely stupid. Looking back, these reading goals and timeframes I set myself were pretty unrealistic. I used to force myself to read dull, lengthy historical or political non-fictional books, thinking that this would miraculously and instantly exacerbate my intelligence and look impressive when people looked at my GoodReads profile. But in reality, I was so bored and unengaged reading these books that I would almost go as far as saying that it was counterproductive for me to read them. 

I used to religiously track everything I read and used to put so much pressure on myself to check books off my ‘to be read’ list within a certain timeframe

Like all other types of social media, a public Goodreads account can make you worry about what others think of you. In other words, it can suck the element of relaxation out of reading. Recreational reading, in my opinion, should be an opportunity for you to escape from whatever worries occupy you in daily life, tracking your reading and making whatever you read accessible for anyone to view adds additional stress or anxiety, however subtle. Reading is something for you, and for you only. What you choose to read shouldn’t be something that others are allowed to scrutinise. If you feel like reading a lengthy historical non-fiction book, great, if that’s what helps you relax then go for it. Equally, if you feel like reading a shorter trashy rom-com you do you. The definition of a book that helps you to relax and zone out of the real world filled with stress and responsibility is different for everyone. 

Since transitioning from my hyper-fixation of book-tracking and protecting my public image as a reader in the age of social media, I’ve rediscovered the joy of reading. I’ve realised that not every book I pick up has to be an intellectually impressive feat. ‘Easy’ fictional reads have really genuinely helped me manage stress, anxiety and even homesickness whilst I’ve been away on my year abroad. I used to think that every book I read had to be related in some way to my degree but realistically, tuning my mind into a different language when trying (with often limited success) to read material in French or in Arabic is in no way relaxing. 

The definition of a book that helps you to relax and zone out of the real world filled with stress and responsibility is different for everyone

Now, I find it most relaxing and productive to read something as distant to whatever I am studying as possible to disengage my mind. Weirdly, reading rom-coms and naff crime thrillers is actually more productive for my studies and for my mental heath, as it allows me to manage my stress which in turn, benefits my sleep cycle. 

I’ve recently made my GoodReads profile private. I keep a tab of the books I read, mainly just so I can remember them, but no longer embark on reading challenges and try not to dwell on the number that appears under my ‘read’ column. I am interested in book recommendations from friends and family and equally enjoy recommending books that I have particularly enjoyed, but now I think of this exchange differently: the exchange of recommending books and receiving recommendations shouldn’t have anything to do with social status and shouldn’t be an opportunity to pass judgement. Most importantly, reading is something unique to each individual and should remain that way.

Image Credit: ellen.w on Flickr.