Is F1 destined for an electric future?

By Harvey Finnegan

Formula One has always prided itself on being at the cutting edge of automotive technology. Since the championship began in 1950, F1 has been leading the charge with transferring technology to your everyday road car. From adaptive suspension and aerodynamics, to introducing the most efficient hybrid engines the world has seen, technological evolution is an intrinsic part of the pinnacle of motorsport.

But heading towards the mid-2020s and beyond, F1 is facing an engine dilemma. No one can escape the fact that we are in the early stages of an electric revolution. The UK has already announced a ban on the sale of new petrol and diesel cars by 2030 and most companies are introducing electric vehicles into production. Given F1’s DNA then, transitioning to all electric engines seems like the only option to prevent the sport becoming a relic of the past.

Electrification has already infiltrated motorsport through the all-electric Formula E series. Conceived in 2011 by Alejandro Agag and quickly boasting some top manufacturers like Audi and Renault, it seemed F1 may have been caught off guard. To cement this matter, FE has exclusivity on electric powertrains until 2039, meaning F1 would need to formalise an agreement to be able to use any form of electric engine.

Transitioning to all electric engines seems like the only option to prevent the sport becoming a relic of the past

But the electrification of motorsport is (no-pun intended) appearing to stall. Motorsport is an entertainment business first and foremost and the screaming roar of engines vibrating through your body is a factor in the excitement, adrenaline, and rush that the millions of fans flocking to races across the world desire. Electric race cars are argued to lack this crucial aspect with their sound analogous to a dentil drill. 

For all its initial intrigue, the numbers do not lie. Formula E received a cumulative television audience of 316 million in 2021. In the same year, F1’s cumulative audience was 1.55 billion. To give Formula E credit, the series has put major pressure on motorsports to tackle their carbon footprint, after becoming the first carbon neutral global sport. Nevertheless, its popularity is not growing at a rate that would make F1 executives sweat just yet.

A more fundamental issue with FE is how far away it is from the impressive car performance benchmarks laid out by F1. FE cars have a lower top speed of 175 mph relative to F1’s 230 mph. Moreover, the electric engine forces FE tracks to be flat and uneventful, with lots of heavy breaking zones to allow for battery regeneration across a 45-minute race. F1 races demand significantly faster lap times across double the race length.

While electric technology is developing, embarrassing races such as the 2021 Valencia E-Prix – where 12 drivers ran out of electricity on the last lap of the race – have held the legitimacy of electric racing back. As ex-FIA president Jean Todt highlighted, a present conversion to electricity would be ‘’simply impossible’’. Uninspiring characteristics and viewership figures have given Formula E a mixed reputation from motorsport fans.

A more fundamental issue with FE is how far away it is from the impressive car performance benchmarks laid out by F1

Recent trends have not outlined clear support for electric motorsport from manufacturers either. Both Audi and BMW left the FE championship in recent years, while a new hypercar class in the fossil-fuel based World Endurance Championship – best known for the 24 hours of Le Mans – has eight manufacturers (including Ferrari, BMW and Porsche) flocking to join for 2024.

At present, F1 has four engine manufacturers using V6 turbo hybrid engines. They currently use an E10 fuel consisting of 10% bioethanol and 90% fossil fuel. This is the first step in creating a fuel which has a net-zero carbon footprint. The current issue with bioethanol relates to a lack of efficacy relative to fossil fuels and the fact that existing engines need modifications to accommodate a higher percentage of bioethanol. The solution under development involves a fully sustainable ‘drop in’ fuel which negates these issues and could even be used to power the everyday road car. 

Biofuels are currently having billions invested into them whereby sugars from biowaste can be converted into hydrocarbons. Porsche have been pioneering an alternate ‘drop-in’ fuel called e-fuel. They have already invested $75 million into establishing a synthetic fuel factory in Chile. These e-fuels take waste carbon dioxide and hydrogen to create the hydrocarbon fuel.

The Volkswagen group has recently announced its intent to enter Audi into the 2026 F1 World Championship and a potential Porsche entry remains on the cards. This would likely pave the way for F1’s 2026 commitment to operate using a fully sustainable fuel.

By 2030, 1.8 billion cars are expected to be on the road with only 8% being electric

The vast cost implications of implementing satisfactory infrastructure, alongside the price of purchasing such vehicles – particularly in developing countries – provides a substantial environmental argument in favour of carbon neutral drop in fuels. By 2030, 1.8 billion cars are expected to be on the road with only 8% being electric. Moreover, electric batteries are not energy-dense enough to be considered in mainstream aviation or naval transport solution. Again, we see a case for alternate methods of decarbonisation.

Aside from the environmental case outlined, carbon neutral fuels solve the seemingly inescapable sound problem faced by electric engines. Acting like any other fossil fuel, carbon neutral fuels will allow internal combustion to remain in motorsports (and the wider world). Sebastian Vettel showcased this by driving his 1992 Williams FW14B running on a 100% carbon neutral biofuel.

This has opened the door for speculation that F1 may abandon the hybrid engine altogether for the more popular V10 engine. In the long-term future then, F1 could ditch engine road-relevancy altogether in favour of a carbon-neutral version of the engines that generations of fans adore.

As the sport reaches a crossroads regarding the future of its engines, the electric revolution that is sweeping the world is not necessarily going to translate to F1. While remaining committed to achieving a carbon-neutral fuel within this decade, F1’s long term engine choice is by no means given.

Image: Infiniti via Flickr