Is drill music the cause of escalating violence?

By Xhulio Ismalaj 

UK drill, a musical subgenre of US-originated Chicago drill, typically contains lyrics detailing gang activity and, subsequently, has been blamed for a significant increase in violence throughout London during a year in which knife crime in England and Wales has reached a peak not seen since 2010. But can we really blame drill artists for this increase in crime, or does the answer lie elsewhere?

Met Police Commisioner Cressida Dick accused drill music of inciting the rise in violence within London

Drill music within the UK has seen massive growth in recent years, with even global superstar Drake recording a Link Up TV Behind Barz freestyle on a drill-fused instrumental. The UK edition of drill has even managed to return to its origin in the US, with the creation of ‘Pitbulls’ by Skegdo & AM featuring drill pioneer Chief Keef.

In May, Met Police Commissioner Cressida Dick accused drill music of inciting the rise in violence within London, and consequently removed more than thirty drill music videos from online platforms. To add to this negative institutional response, Former Home Secretary, Amber Rudd, correlated the increase in violence across the capital with these music videos appearing online.

Social media plays a pivotal role in the distribution of drill music

Those against drill claim that egotistic, posturing artists are glorifying gang culture and consequently normalising acts of murder, drug abuse and robbery through their music. The standardisation of this form of criminal activity, they believe, is likely to influence those in vulnerable situations to commit crime. Some would even go so far as to claim that the threatening of individuals by virtue of music should be treated as a standard threat – perhaps even of a terrorist nature.

Social media plays a pivotal role in the distribution of drill music. Instagram pages, such as UK Drill News (UDN), are thought to perpetuate violence by acting as an intermediary between opposing gangs. The audience of drill music and the subsequent social media content encourage the gangs in question to commit violent acts. The pressure of committing to what is claimed in lyrics is constant among drill artists and can eventually lead to actual violent enactment of threats.

The question of whether drill music breeds violence or whether drill music is the consequence of violence bares many similaries with the old-age philosophical question of the chicken and the egg

Sadiq Khan, however, attributes blame of the significant increase in violence throughout London to cuts in police officers. Khan, in July, stated: “We’ve seen over the last seven years in London a loss of more than 3,000 police officers, on top of that we’ve lost more than 3,000 community officers and on top of that, we’ve lost more than 3,000 police staff.” The Closure of over 600 youth clubs in the UK since 2010 austerity measures were implemented has also been cited as a major contribution to the ripple effect of violence seen today.

The question of whether drill music breeds violence or whether drill music is the consequence of violence bears many similarities with the old-age philosophical question of the chicken and the egg. Music, in general, has been blamed for the criminality of youth for generations. Indeed, in the 1950s, Rock was cited as a factor for the increase in drug use amongst youth.

Scribz, a member of the well-known drill group 67, believes that drill music can have a positive influence on an artists life. In a BBC Newsnight segment, he notes the opportunity for self-expression: “You’re way more productive; you’re way more creative; you come up with ideas. It gives you more knowledge.”

Drill music can also provide a means of escaping a disadvantageous socio-economic situation, through revenue from YouTube, merchandise, festivals and tours. Indeed, Scribz follows on to allude to the potential for financial gain: “You start learning business. You’re getting paid from it so now you can deal with your rent. You can feed your family. You can take trips.”

Creators of drill music argue that the often graphic lyrics are a representation of the hardships that they are faced with, and the banning of drill music has removed the opportunity for some young creators to break from their underprivileged background. In their eyes, the censoring of drill music will only lead to alternative methods of violent expression.

Drill artists can be beacons of inspiration for the younger generation, as some artists headline festival stages and have their music played on prime-time TV. Drill artists do not necessarily have to be drill artists forever, either. They can step into the mainstream. An artist can breakthrough with drill music, but expand to alternative genres, as seen by Loski who released melodic songs such as afroswing-influenced ‘Forrest Gump’.

When looking at solutions for the escalation in violence, one must acknowledge the requirement for a stronger line of communication between government and the underprivileged. Drill creators should be seen as genuine professionals paving a career within the music industry, as opposed to unresponsive criminals. The removal of Instagram pages which act as an intermediary between gangs, such as UDN, can be a step towards preventing the instigation of violence.

Photograph: amy mergard from Creative Commons via Flickr