Is British intervention necessary in the Syrian crisis?

By Adam Smith

In the wake of the recent attack by Islamic State in Paris which left 130 dead, Europe remains on high alert; a palpable sense of uncertainty lingers. With the nihilistic brutality of the Islamic State seemingly no longer confined to the Middle East their barbaric reach has extended insidiously to metropolises throughout Europe. The fact that the violence unfolded on London’s doorstep and the sheer scale of the bloodshed understandably elicits a strong emotional response, driving an urge to strike back against ISIS in its strategic heartland in Syria. This primal need for a tangible retaliation against an enemy that seems to be advancing ever-closer to us has given fresh impetus to David Cameron’s plans to extend British bombing of ISIS to Syria; a vote in the Commons on the matter appears to be an inevitability. With Britain already bombing ISIS targets in Iraq, Cameron argues extending this to include Syria is logical and crucial to national security. His reasoning that every day of inaction allows ISIS to grow stronger and foster more plots of terror against Britain certainly seems to be gaining momentum with both Conservative and Labour MPs.

Britain appears poised to join the US-led coalition that is already targeting ISIS in Syria in an attempt to degrade the terrorist organisation and neutralise its threat to Europe. The impending threat that ISIS poses certainly appears on the face of it as though intervening in Syria is action we must unequivocally take. This compulsion to intervene, spurred on by the Paris attacks – to do something, anything, to curb violent jihadism – needs to be carefully considered in light of the West’s historically disastrous military interventions in the Arab world. Those nations already bombing Syria have done little to disrupt ISIS, this due to the militants rarely presenting a purely military target – their infrastructure is carefully intertwined amongst the civilian population. The idea that the addition of British aircraft to the coalition airstrikes will yield increased results is naive. The situation is far too complex to be resolved by the dropping of bombs, and may in fact play into the hands of ISIS’ recruitment strategy, allowing them to paint Britain as a crusader in Muslim lands.

The complexity of the enduring civil war in Syria, with its multitude of warring factions with shifting allegiances and ambiguous motives, presents a murky picture in which to intervene. An effective air campaign would require an army on the ground to coordinate them against ISIS. There simply is not a coherent military force to credibly lend our support to in Syria. The choice we face is between the support of genocidal Bashar al-Assad, or the support of a patchwork of rebel forces who oppose his regime, some of whom are equally abhorrent. Cameron’s plan for intervention in Syria rests on support from the Free Syrian Army on the ground, but even Julian Lewis, who chairs the Commons Defence Committee, stated it was dubious whether they would be able to provide the requisite support to make airstrikes effective. There exists no evidence that the Free Syrian Army is more than an assortment of tribal clans and militias, and no way to guarantee they are moderate non-Islamist fighters. Supporting any of these forces with Britain’s relatively insignificant aerial firepower against ISIS is fraught with difficulties and will have marginal benefits. The addition of British aircraft to the coalition looks more like a political gesture, a signal to France and America that Britain is standing with its allies. Bombing Syria could make Britain a bigger target for Paris-style attacks and with little sign that it will help to bring any stability to the region or destroy ISIS it seems a foolish gesture to make.

What must be considered is the enemy that France and Europe are grappling with does not originate from Syria; the majority of the Paris attackers were European citizens. The deprived hinterlands of Brussels and other European capitals is where this jihadism thrives. Clearly a Muslim minority within Europe are alienated, radical, and susceptible to the call of violent jihadism and no amount of bombing in Syria is going to dislodge these beliefs. The root of this disaffection from Western society is the issue that needs to be tackled to truly stop reoccurrences of the Paris attacks. The battle against jihadism will be won not with warplanes and bombs but by our intelligence agencies and other initiatives aimed at this radicalised core within. Undoubtedly ISIS needs to be defeated but military intervention is not the answer; a wider diplomatic strategy is needed to tackle the many-headed hydra of violent jihadism.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are not representative of Palatinate, and are those of the author only. If you disagree with the opinions expressed, or would like to write for Palatinate in response, please contact the Politics Section at politics@palatinate.org.uk

Photograph: D B Young via Flickr